Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Reloading results...

Suggestions for Italian Restaurant near Eltingville, NY

Filters:
    • 7.6

      1. Giovannis Trattoria

      Italian • $$$$ •
      3800 richmond avenue, Staten Island
      Save
    • 7.3

      2. All Star Cafe

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      680 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Star 3 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 7.0

      3. Portobello Cafe

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      4221 Hylan Blvd (Robinson Ave), Staten Island
      Save
      • Star 2 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 8.2

      4. Campania Coal Fired Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      3900 Richmond Ave (Amboy Road), Staten Island
      Save
      • Jill M.

        Jill M. • April 5, 2016Best pizza hands down on Staten.. the mussels in the pot are outstanding too!

    • 6.6

      5. Euro Pizza

      Italian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      3271 Richmond Ave, Staten Island
      Save
      • Star 41 items on the menu match Italian food
    • Category icon
      ?

      6. Filoncino Cafe

      Italian • $$$$ •
      4569 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Demetrius B.

        Demetrius B. • February 6, 2019Hearing their vegan options are outstanding. Those are pizzas, sandwiches, salads, and a whole bakery shelf including yodells (!!!), rainbow cookies, and cookies

    • ?

      7. Trattoria Toscana

      Italian • $$$$ •
      4200 Hylan Blvd (Armstrong Avenue), Staten Island
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?

      8. La Stanza

      Italian • $$$$ •
      3900 Richmond Ave, Staten Island
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?

      9. puglia's of Hester Street

      Italian • $$$$ •
      4200 Hylan Blvd (Armstrong Ave. and Robinson Ave.), Staten Island
      Save
      • RoseAnn B.

        RoseAnn B. • December 8, 2016The Chicken ala Debra was delicious

    • 8.6

      10. Pastosa Ravioli

      Gourmet •
      3817 Richmond Ave, Staten Island
      Save
      • Kerry S.

        Kerry S. • December 2, 2013Best ravioli on the island

    • Category icon
      ?

      11. Pronto Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      3297 Richmond Ave (Brandis Ave.), Staten Island
      Save
      • Star 173 items on the menu match Italian food
    • ?

      12. Giuseppes Pizza Thin And Crispy

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      4300 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Phil D.

        Phil D. • July 16, 2010Fantastic thin and crispy pizza! Try it you won't be disappointed!!!

    • ?

      13. Sal's And Lloyd's Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      3850 Richmond Ave, Staten Island
      Save
      • Star 52 items on the menu match Italian food
    • Category icon
      ?

      14. Valducci's Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      Staten Island
      Save
      • Mike P.

        Mike P. • February 19, 2011Used to be good years ago. I haven't ate there for probably a year now because their pizza changed from the best to the grossest pizza I ever had.

    • Category icon
      ?

      15. Frank And Danny's

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      4369 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Star 36 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 7.9

      16. Kiku Sushi

      Sushi • $$$$ • View Menu •
      3838 Richmond Ave (at Eltingville Blvd.), Staten Island
      Save
      • Mike O.

        Mike O. • January 18, 2013Tuna Pizza is a must.

    • 8.2

      17. Alfonso's Pastry Shop

      Bakery • $$$$ • View Menu •
      4366 Amboy Rd (4366 Amboy Rd), Staten Island
      Save
      • Star 13 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 8.3

      18. Ralph's Ices

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      3245 Richmond Ave, Staten Island
      Save
      • Brian M.

        Brian M. • July 29, 2018The Creme ices are delicious 🔥

    • 8.5

      19. Ralph's Italian Ices

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      4212 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Heidi D.

        Heidi D. • May 13, 2016Amazing Italian ices and ice cream! Best you will ever have!!

    • 7.2

      20. The Richmond Diner

      Diner • $$$$ • View Menu •
      3954 Richmond Ave, Staten Island
      Save
      • Star 19 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 7.3

      21. TOMO Japanese Cuisine

      Sushi • $$$$ • View Menu •
      4561A Amboy Rd., Staten Island
      Save
      • Star 2 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 6.5

      22. Bagel Depot

      Deli • $$$$ • View Menu •
      3854 Richmond Ave, Staten Island
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches Italian food
    • 6.9

      23. Planet Wings

      Wings • $$$$ •
      698 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Faye H.

        Faye H. • January 25, 2012Best wings on the island next to pronto pizza

    • 5.9

      24. Boston Market

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      854 Arthur Kill Rd (Arthur Kill Rd), Staten Island
      Save
      • Star 6 items on the menu match Italian food
    • 6.0

      25. Subway

      Sandwich Spot • $$$$ • View Menu •
      4348B Amboy Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Star 16 items on the menu match Italian food
    • Category icon
      6.5

      26. Baskin-Robbins

      Ice Cream • $$$$ • View Menu •
      680 Arthur Kill Rd (Abingdon), Staten Island
      Save
      • Star 7 items on the menu match Italian food
    • Category icon
      ?

      27. Oriental Taste

      Asian • $$$$ • View Menu •
      3279 Richmond Ave, Staten Island
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches Italian food

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.