Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Reloading results...

Suggestions for Dining and Drinking near Eltingville

Filters:
    • 8.5
      Ice Cream$$$$
      4212 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Heidi D.

        Heidi D. • May 13, 2016Amazing Italian ices and ice cream! Best you will ever have!!

    • 8.3
      Ice Cream$$$$
      3245 Richmond Ave, Staten Island
      Save
      • Sean F.

        Sean F. • May 6, 2014Cookie Monster is back! Also the cinnamon roll is amazing (if it's actually in).

    • 8.2
      Pizza$$$$
      3900 Richmond Ave (Amboy Road), Staten Island
      Save
      • Jessica

        Jessica • November 25, 2014Dropped in for a light nosh with my bf, and glad we did! Ordered the burrata special and shrimp oregonata appetizer to share, very tasty. I had the special lentil soup, and it reminded me of my moms.

    • 8.2
      Bakery$$$$View Menu
      4366 Amboy Rd (4366 Amboy Rd), Staten Island
      Save
      • Roseann L.

        Roseann L. • April 13, 2015It's an incredible taste experience to bite into lobster tail pastry!

    • 8.0
      Bagels$$$$
      4300 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Emily Z.

        Emily Z. • September 30, 2017Crazy good cereal bagels! Open all night too.

    • 7.9
      Coffee Shop$$$$
      4357 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • David G.

        David G. • July 2, 2015Love their grilled chicken salads. Country donuts coffee is superior to Dunken. Don't ever change your coffee. It's the best!

    • 7.9
      Sushi$$$$View Menu
      3838 Richmond Ave (at Eltingville Blvd.), Staten Island
      Save
      • Larry

        Larry • November 10, 2012Monster King Crab was absolutely wonderful. Spicy and paired lovingly with the mango.

    • 7.7
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      4350 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
      Save
    • 7.6
      Italian$$$$
      3800 richmond avenue, Staten Island
      Save
      • Kat O.

        Kat O. • July 9, 2014Never had a bad meal. Great owners and great staff.

    • 7.6
      Ice Cream$$$$View Menu
      4332 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Liz C.

        Liz C. • June 28, 2012Love their soft serve ice cream and milkshakes :)

    • 7.5
      Sushi$$$$View Menu
      4215 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Jill M.

        Jill M. • April 26, 2013Great rolls.. They make them without rice wrapped in cucumber. ... Delish

    • 7.3
      Sushi$$$$View Menu
      4561A Amboy Rd., Staten Island
      Save
      • Felix G.

        Felix G. • September 1, 2016The fish was fresh and tasty, the service was great! The waitress recommendations were spot-on!

    • 7.3
      Italian$$$$View Menu
      680 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Corinne F.

        Corinne F. • August 7, 2014The mixed salad with grilled chicken and roasted red peppers is the best

    • 7.2
      Diner$$$$View Menu
      3954 Richmond Ave, Staten Island
      Save
      • Church B.

        Church B. • March 10, 2013They have fantastic Swiss cheese!! And great chocolate shakes

    • 7.2
      Burgers$$$$
      4318 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Emily Z.

        Emily Z. • January 25, 2016burgers are perfectly cooked and the milkshakes are super tasty.

    • 7.2
      Fast Food$$$$View Menu
      25 Putnam St (Amboy Rd), Staten Island
      Save
      • Steve M.

        Steve M. • June 6, 2019Foods good but you’ll spend 20 bucks on 2 combos . Which when we got it wasn’t worth it at all. That’s why I don’t eat fast food that much.

    • 7.1
      Coffee Shop$$$$
      794-868 Arthur Kill Rd., Staten Island
      Save
      • Joseph H.

        Joseph H. • January 8, 2017Fabulous coffee, donuts, and vegetable cream cheese.

    • 7.0
      Chinese$$$$View Menu
      4326 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Stacey

        Stacey • March 3, 2013Yummy crispy noodles and great service. Sesame chicken is tasty!!

    • 7.0
      Italian$$$$View Menu
      4221 Hylan Blvd (Robinson Ave), Staten Island
      Save
      • Visit L.

        Visit L. • November 10, 2014Everything was delicious. Service fantastic as always. Alyssa was very sweet.

    • 6.9
      Wings$$$$
      698 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Church B.

        Church B. • April 6, 2013Cajun Wings are great

    • Category icon
      6.9
      Sushi$$$$
      4371 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Nina L.

        Nina L. • December 28, 2012Pretty good sushi for the price - go with the Lover-Lover roll!

    • 6.8
      Sushi$$$$
      4342 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
      Save
      • Phil D.

        Phil D. • July 12, 2010Best sushi in Eltingville by far! Beats Tomo hands down

    • 6.8
      Bar$$$$View Menu
      3830-3832 Richmond Ave, Staten Island
      Save
      • Joseph H.

        Joseph H. • January 4, 2017Great food , fabulous drinks. Very pleasant staff.

    • 6.7
      Café$$$$View Menu
      3845 Richmond Ave, Staten Island
      Save
    • 6.6
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      3271 Richmond Ave, Staten Island
      Save
      • Danielle K.

        Danielle K. • December 31, 2011This pizza is amazing!!chicken vodka slices are amazing along with the wrap!!!

    • 6.6
      Gastropub$$$$
      4459 Amboy Rd (Richmond Ave), Staten Island
      Save
    • 6.5
      Deli$$$$View Menu
      3854 Richmond Ave, Staten Island
      Save
      • Jonathan P.

        Jonathan P. • December 8, 2011The flavored cream cheese is awesome

    • Category icon
      6.5
      Ice Cream$$$$View Menu
      680 Arthur Kill Rd (Abingdon), Staten Island
      Save
    • 6.5
      Donuts$$$$View Menu
      680 Arthur Kill Rd (At Armstrong Ave), Staten Island
      Save
      • Eddie

        Eddie • August 22, 2011Awesome iced coffee I always ask for a little bit less ice get more coffee out of it.

    • 6.3
      Fast Food$$$$View Menu
      3901 Richmond Ave (Amboy Rd), Staten Island
      Save
      • Church B.

        Church B. • June 11, 2013This Burger King is pretty good, sometimes annoying service.

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.