Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Reloading results...

Suggestions for Pizzeria near Carmel

Filters:
    • 9.2
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      12697 N Pennsylvania St,, Carmel
      Save
      • Robert S.

        Robert S. • December 31, 2015We always love building our own pizzas. Be sure to try the blood orange lemonade!

    • 8.5
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      111 W Main St (at 2nd Av W), Carmel
      Save
      • Evan

        Evan • August 8, 2014Bazbeaux easily has the best pizza in town. My personal favorite is pepperoni or pepperoni and sausage. Make sure to order the froze lemon desert. It's a frozen treat served inside of a lemon rind.

    • 8.5
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      2340 E 116th St (Keystone Avenue), Carmel
      Save
    • 8.2
      Pizza$$$$
      14550 Clay Terrace Blvd, Suite 100, Carmel
      Save
      • Romily B.

        Romily B. • October 22, 2023Post picking up Keri and picking up a car.

    • 9.0
      Pizza$$$$
      1732 E 116th St (116th & Rangeline Rd), Carmel
      Save
      • Kelly A.

        Kelly A. • July 31, 2011Sals Spicy Pie is the bomb!

    • 8.0
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      2764 E 146th St, Carmel
      Save
      • Robert S.

        Robert S. • December 31, 2015Try the deep dish! I don't usually like deep dish, but I like Jets!

    • 8.0
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      13190 Hazel Dell Pkwy (at Hazel Dell, behind Starbucks), Carmel
      Save
      • caleb d.

        caleb d. • September 5, 2011Tony's Fritters appetizer is a great way to kick off your meal. Nice local craft beer selection.

    • 7.7
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      13674 N Meridian St, Carmel
      Save
      • Andre B.

        Andre B. • March 12, 2022Great pizza! The crust gives it an edge over others.

    • 7.7
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1450 Clay Terrace Blvd., Carmel
      Save
      • Travis B.

        Travis B. • March 11, 2013Really good pizza and fast if you get it by the slice. They have a lot of breadsticks and other sides to choose from.

    • 7.6
      Pizza$$$$
      2430 E 146th St, Carmel
      Save
      • Mikey R.

        Mikey R. • February 24, 2012Excellent, friendly, service. We never needed to look for our waitress!

    • 7.5
      Pizza$$$$
      11435 Springmill Rd, Carmel
      Save
      • rKS

        rKS • October 22, 2020Be ready to play bumper cars... place is going to crazy for a minute.

    • 7.3
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      4335 W 106th St, Carmel
      Save
      • Brandon

        Brandon • November 23, 2009Go with the Monster Deep Dish pizza minus the onions + black olives -- you wont regret it.

    • 7.3
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1311 S Rangeline Rd (in Carmel Walk strip mall), Carmel
      Save
      • Chris T.

        Chris T. • May 4, 2013Love the thin crust. Robin is awesome-great customer service!

    • 7.3
      Pizza$$$$
      890 E 116th St #100 (at Guilford Road), Carmel
      Save
      • Brit

        Brit • August 7, 2012Breadsticks with pepperoni are amazing

    • 7.5
      PizzaView Prices
      617 3rd Ave SW (City Center Drive), Carmel
      Save
      • Eva L.

        Eva L. • May 7, 20103 for the price of 2 sessions after 8pm

    • 7.4
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      465 E Carmel Dr (at AAA Way), Carmel
      Save
      • Tony W.

        Tony W. • September 26, 2012Pizza baked spaghetti is pretty good ... especially supremo!

    • 6.8
      Pizza$$$$
      1 E Carmel Dr Ste 170 (at Range Line Rd), Carmel
      Save
      • Brandan H.

        Brandan H. • January 30, 2012Alfredo based pizza with grilled chicken and diced tomatoes is the best

    • 6.8
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      2001 E Greyhound Pass Ste 7, Carmel
      Save
      • Nick Z.

        Nick Z. • July 16, 2010XL 3 - topping pizza for just $12 (P.S. the crust is amazing)

    • 6.6
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1441 S Guilford Rd Ste 110, Carmel
      Save
      • Paul L.

        Paul L. • December 12, 2010Get extra sauce on your pie--it's free, plus I think the sauce (as opposed to cheese) is what really makes a pizza a pizza.

    • 6.6
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      10598 N College Ave (106th), Carmel
      Save
      • Craig G.

        Craig G. • September 24, 2010Mention this and receive a free lg pizza

    • 6.3
      Pizza$$$$
      4400 Weston Pointe Dr (Suite 160), Zionsville
      Save
      • Allison J.

        Allison J. • June 30, 2012HotBox is the best pizza chain in Indianapolis. Get their thin crust Four Cheese pizza and you MUST get their bread stix.

    • 6.0
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      4100 W 106th St (at N Michigan Rd), Carmel
      Save
      • Drew D.

        Drew D. • September 18, 2014Friendly staff. Free wifi. Great pizza!

    • 5.9
      Pizza$$$$
      120 E Main St, Carmel
      Save
      • Jeremiah C.

        Jeremiah C. • December 11, 2017The “Last Call” pizza deal is where it’s at!

    • 5.8
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      705 S. Rangeline Road (Rangeline Rd & City Center Dr), Carmel
      Save
      • Chris M.

        Chris M. • August 24, 2018Do you need plates? Ask for plates at no additional fee.

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      1224 S Guilford Rd, Carmel
      Save
    • ?
      Pizza$$$$
      351 Monon Blvd, Carmel
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      14931 Greyhound Ct, Carmel
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      Carmel
      Save
    • ?
      Pizza$$$$
      12703 Meeting House Rd, Carmel
      Save
    • ?
      Pizza$$$$
      Carmel
      Save
    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.