Grace K. • July 31, 2016The first place I ever had rolled ice cream. It's super fun to watch them make the ice cream, and the results are delicious.
Stephanie G. • March 10, 2015Shake shack is well known for their delicious burgers and fries! But their hot chocolate is also one of the best I ever tasted. Highly recommend
Lori L. • July 24, 2016An old school ice cream parlor, complete with sundaes, shakes, milkshakes, floats, and more. Get one of their signature sundaes to share, or make your own version if you're feeling creative,
Nilay G. • July 5, 2019Italian ices are really good - they come in every flavor that they have for ice cream
Nushy S. • March 17, 2015I'm a big chocolate fan but when it comes to cakes I think Strawberry Passion is the best.
eric b. • December 28, 2023A staple of Brooklyn now no matter the price. Good interesting flavors keep you coming back.
Margaret W. • August 22, 2014The salted caramel crack ice cream is phenomenal. Solid flavor choices, and good local ingredients.
Max B. • April 25, 2019This location has the new summer flavors! Vegan Oat Milk is Columbian coffee ice cream with chocolate fudge swirls, simply the best!
Sue E. • November 5, 2017Great coffee shop close to the waters to stop by. Liked their coffee and lots of space to study
Jeremy F. • May 26, 2021Haven’t had Oddfellows in years, and was shocked at how good it is these days
Robin D. • August 20, 2022I only get Butter Pecan on a cake cone. Not because the other flavors aren’t good. Butter Pecan is all I ever get anywhere. Their Butter Pecan is fabulous. I highly recommend it.
Christina C. • May 2, 2023Just opened, took over the Brooklyn ice cream old place. Some indoor seating and mwrch for sale in there too. Can sample the flavors!
Julyane L. • November 10, 2017Ameii o sorvete daqui! ❤️
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.