Suggestions for American Restaurant near Bay View, Milwaukee

Jen S. • March 13, 2015The Currywurst and Duck BLT are both great! Bring a friend and go halfsies on one! Awesome beer selection too.

Eric B. • June 13, 2021Unique and tasty cocktails, small plates, and a queer friendly staff!

Jen S. • August 16, 2010The burger is amazing (minus the egg). The grilled cheese with apples & bacon pairs very well with the tomato carrot soup.

Lauren J. • July 11, 2019Our server Joel was amazing! There was a mistake and our food wasn't made - comped our meal, was so apologetic and gave us free chai teas with our dessert!

Stacy • April 13, 2014They did a great job with the space, having seen it before. The food is moderately priced (we had 3 dishes, 2 desserts, & 1 beer for around $55). Everything we had we liked. Try the homemade Kit Kat.

Hop Leaf Beer H. • June 16, 2013Fish fry & seafood shack by the water. Great hidden spot to have a beer outdoors. Some local brews available. After staying here for the sunset, head to Sugar Maple nearby for 60+ craft beers on tap.

Jason G. • June 22, 2010gotta get the blackened chicken sandwich with hush puppies and vegan ranch. Outstanding!

Lauren J. • February 13, 2021The homemade pasta was delicious but the experience could've been better. If I'm dining out I don't want to eat my food out of to go containers. I wish you got more bread with the bread and burrata!

Ryan Y. • January 3, 2012Very pleasant experience. Food was great and service was friendly and superb.

JenKudu • September 14, 2016The decor, the staff, the food.. A+. The plates were creative and the cocktails well balanced. So good, we bought the kitchen a round :)

Jennifer H. • March 18, 2017Great options for vegetarians and vegans - the veg ceviche and guacamole were especially good.

A.J. B. • April 2, 2023Skip entrees, and opt for the river front views/patio for drinks. Harbor House, Lupe & Iris better options – food, service, decor/design, pricing – for Modern American.

Sarah H. • January 10, 2019The Aguagate Rellano with steak was amazing! Also enjoyed the sangria and the coquito immensely. The El Jibarito sandwich was really flavorful, but messy to eat.