"Dortoni's is my favorite bakery on Long Island."(2 Tips)
"beautiful cakes and pastries!"(2 Tips)
"Cannoli and cookies were so fresh made the dessert platter perfect"(6 Tips)
"Awesome cakes and cupcakes."(2 Tips)
26 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- cake
- pastries
- cookies
- bakeries
- cupcakes
- (11 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Kenneth LindDecember 19, 2018Amazing everything. All pasties, breads are fresh. Have been coming here for years. Hasn’t changed.
Andrew SchusterDecember 29, 2017Everything is fantastic. Cannolis, Tarts, Cookies, the Milky Way cake is truly amazing.- Gary BurkeMay 27, 2016You will be very happy with everything you order here. Dortoni's is my favorite bakery on Long Island. They make the best black and white cookies!
You can't go wrong with whatever you get. Hands down, it is the best bakery! Try the rainbow cookies and Italian cookie assortment.- First stop when I’m back on Long Island. Italian cookies are one of the many incredible items.
Jennifer LevitanApril 23, 2012amazing cakes! got 8 of them for my daughters christening and they were all delicious. sicilian cassata was awesome! st. honore was one of the best =D
Best bakery on Long Island. Great selection of cakes, pastries, cookies, & more! Delicious - don't go in hungry
- Ken StaffeyAugust 16, 2013Wow, this place is impressive with all the beautiful cakes and pastries! Must return.
Explore Long IslandFebruary 27, 2013We featured Dortoni Bakery and other stores in our guide for "Great food shops on Long Island!" Read more
54 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 7:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 7:00 AM–9:00 PM
- Sat
- 7:00 AM–9:30 PM
- Sun
- 7:00 AM–8:00 PM
(516) 796-3033
Features
Reservations
No
Outdoor Seating
No
See More
You might also like
- 8.7
"Always good: crannolis, the cup of cappuccino dessert, donuts, iced eclairs, and mini cheesecakes."
Mike Pedersen - 8.6
"I had the Pick Two was the Black Bean Soup with Thai Chicken Salad, & an Apple!"
Marisa Rubin - 6.5
"Great desserts, strawberry shortcake, delicious, but not too sweet, just right."
Mary Jasen
Appears on 22 lists
Created by Kelley
7 itemsCreated by Chef Catman (Just Fork Me)
21 items • 4 followersCreated by Lauren
20 items