Door County Creamery

Café$$$$

Sister Bay

Save

8.4^/10

ratings

"Goat milk ice cream is a big “no” from me."(2 Tips)
"Happy goats make yummy cheese and super creamy gelato."(3 Tips)
"Chèvre Torte sandwich with DoCo Creamery goat cheese is delicious."(5 Tips)
"BTW the cheese is awesome, they are all great!"(6 Tips)

11 Tips and reviews

Filter:

Sort:

Maddie KayeAugust 18, 2016
Seriously some of the best food I've ever had. The cheese plate is always delish, the cheese curd sandwich is insane and the gelato is to die for. Try everything! I highly recommend eating here.
Stacy Bo BacySeptember 7, 2023
Goat milk ice cream is a big “no” from me. Cute shop but every item was made in China. Please support local artists.
Upvoted Aug 27
Morgan RusnakOctober 7, 2014
Been here 25+ times
Feta sandwich is to die for. Finish up with a scoop of salted caramel goat milk gelato.
Marc WestenburgJuly 7, 2013
If you can find it in season, get the wild ramp chevre. Unbelievable.
Kyle KubichekOctober 10, 2020
Picked up food for lunch - was a great meal. Got the lamb gyro and turkey sandwich. Both phenomenal
Kaija JohnsonJune 29, 2013
Happy goats make yummy cheese and super creamy gelato. Try the stracciatella- wow!
Kevin PignoneJune 22, 2014
They have an excellent wine selection that features bottle $20.00 or less. BTW the cheese is awesome, they are all great!
Craig RoloffJune 29, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Chèvre Torte sandwich with DoCo Creamery goat cheese is delicious. Cheesemaster Jesse's best item!
Tim NybergAugust 5, 2013
Must experience! Lunch, snack, tasting... Promo!
No NameAugust 4, 2015
Sandwiches are amazing.
LisaJune 6, 2012
The turtles are awesome.

69 Photos