Vanilla cake w/vanilla icing is the best one at Dessert Gallery, in my opinion! Jenny's Birthday Cake is perfect for a chocolate lover...be forewarned, it's rich! :)
For a delicious PG evening, Dessert Gallery stocks a few board games, or you could always bring your own and camp out in the overstuffed purple armchairs.
Mom's Chocolate Cake is amazing! And, even though I normally hate nuts in carrot cake, the Carrot with Cream Cheese Frostingcupcakes are scrumptious! (ha ha, you said "nuts")