Travel + Leisure: Opened in 1858, this general store is a throwback to an era when every neighborhood had a one-stop shop. Come here for picnic fixings, comic books, and, of course, your morning coffee.
Travel + Leisure: The sashimi and lobster rolls alone are worth the trek to this no-frills, cliffside haunt near the Gay Head Lighthouse in Aquinnah, complete with knockout ocean views.
Travel + Leisure: This is a browser’s paradise of funky furniture and unique finds—quilts from India, jars of homemade mango-lime salsa, and kitchen chairs with denim covers.