Cones
(Now Closed)Ice Cream Parlor$$$$
West Village, New York
The experts at Serious Eats and New York Habitat recommend this place
114 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Celena ChanAugust 3, 2015A solid ice cream place, I come here for the corn flavor which is what makes this place unique from the others! It is so creamy and custard like. Make sure to get the cinnamon on top.
Lula HalperinAugust 24, 2014Best gelato in NYC! I recommend the dulce de leche with chips. I love the zambayon but be advised that it has a really strong liquor flavor. You may want to ask for a sample beforehand.
Joe GermuskaAugust 2, 2013"…this Argentinian gelato shop isn't always at the top of our list. Still, the Argentinian flavors like yerba mate and dulce de leche are solid and the corn gelato is surprisingly awesome."
Alyssa B.June 7, 2022Texture is reminiscent of “street” ice creams of my culture. It’s not buttery smooth as typically expected in artisanal; it’s just nostalgic. Cinnamon is an interesting touch! Pic: corn, honey, PB.
Leslie TengDecember 10, 2015Almond cream and mate flavors are unique and leave you wanting to go back for more. The gelato is very soft and creamy. Also the perfect study break snack.
Cara LauMay 14, 2015Absolutely love the corn, mascarpone, green tea, and pistachio. They don't have a great seating area but walking around the neighbourhood while eating ice cream is better anyway.
While all their flavor are great the standouts are Dulce de leche with chips, and the Corn. You must get cinnamon on the corn. It's fantastic.- corn ice cream with cinnamon! and an array of other great, unique flavors (peanut butter caramel, honeymon, etc.)
JosyJune 26, 2015The zabaglione ice cream reminds me of my favorite cold zabaglione dessert. I love adding a little raspberry sorbet to take this already delectable cone up a notch.
Best ice cream in NYC, in my opinion. Dulce de leche, honey cinnamon & peanut butter caramel are my favorites.
Christina SquitieriMay 26, 2017The corn flavor is really good! (Though I always go for the passionate fruit. Also highly recommend the mint chocolate chip!)
Samiha KhanJuly 2, 2015Tried their sorbet today, passion fruit and lime. It's really good. All ice cream made on premises by hand apparently. Yum.
Serious EatsMarch 17, 2013We're fans of the Argentine-style gelato here, particularly the more distinctive flavors: fresh corn, yerba mate.- Djaniella D.April 13, 2015Try something out of the ordinary and grab the corn ice cream with cinnamon on top!
Sofia BurtonFebruary 14, 2018Cones is amazing. I regularly get cravings for it. Always get cinnamon on your ice cream here.
Amazing corn ice cream. The mate (green tea) is awesome as well, really clear strong flavor
Roger RMay 31, 2016Best dulce de leche ice cream outside of Argentina...try the sweet corn too it's really good!
Dave SawyerApril 12, 2016Try out the Brazilian-style corn ice cream. The flavor and texture are unexpectedly delicious.
Theresa RoldanJuly 10, 2016Good but pricey. Mocha chocolate chip was amazing. White chocolate was a little too sweet
Emerald CatronSeptember 21, 2013Zabayone. Delicious, delicious zabayone. It's not for everyone, but if you like it, then it's heaven.
Con CepvibezAugust 19, 2019White chocolate was great and the service was even better. Great personality
Jessica A.June 27, 2015Great sorbets! All ice creams are mostly handmade by them, so it is very fresh.
Em TAugust 3, 2012Didn't get a chance to try the corn yet but the passion fruit sorbet is so satisfying on a super hot day.
Christina ChinDecember 9, 2016Can get 2 different flavors in a small! Like gelato, about $5. Not the friendliest server
Kyle BeckleyAugust 20, 2011Hands down the best gelato I've ever had. Yes, they have sorbet too, but I don't mind fattening up on hazelnut and tea gelato!
Ms HeleneApril 13, 2014Chocolate non dairy sorbet ! Not sure about the sweet potato and cheese ice cream though
Artisanal ice cream at its best. The corn ice cream changed my life
New York HabitatNovember 29, 2011So many flavors, so little time. We like to keep it simple with the dulce de leche. It never disappoints.
MarinaSeptember 16, 2012Hands down the best gelato in the city. Dulce de leche with chips + banana. Heaven.
Teresa HuiSeptember 21, 2012OH.EM.GEE. Corn ice cream with cinnamon on top and fresh whipped cream = DA BOMB!
Chris C. @ Shared AppetiteJune 3, 2012What to get? Corn ice cream with a light sprinkle of cinnamon and/or the dulce de leche!
Tai COctober 23, 2011beautiful artisan ice cream. they actually had whiskey infused ice ream....sooo good! :)
186 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Artisanal, hand-made Ice Cream and Gelato is alive and well in New York's West Village.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 1:00 PM–11:00 PM
(212) 414-1795
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Dessert
See More
You might also like
- 9.3
"This cold creamy deliciousness is worth every penny. There is so much to choose from with some flavor combos you don't see too often. Assortment of toppings and sauces to drizzle on your selection"
ℳ𝒶𝓎♍ - 8.3
"Love this place, Cookies and cream is my goto, but coconut custard (seasonal) is amazing"
Lee Hoffman - 8.9
"It's worth the money. Good quality and great service. Plus you can get as many flavors as you like."
Emily K.
Places people like to go after Cones
- 9.5
"I love coming here for the entertainment. Piano is my favorite."
Jaclyn Lam - 9.5
"They do a lot of fun events and classes upstairs. Really good selection and gourmet items downstairs!"
Paige C - 9.1
"This theater screens some of the best in independent cinema. It also screens great anime from time to time, both new and classic. It's a great place to catch great films."
Chris Raghoobar
Appears on 317 lists
Created by New York Habitat
44 items • 316 followers
New York City's Best Ice Cream Shops
Created by Foursquare Swarm
20 items • 288 followers
Created by Serious Eats
41 items • 216 followers