Caroline's Cafe
American Restaurant, Bar, and Breakfast Spot$$$$
Key West
"Dolphin fingers hit the spot 👌👌"(3 Tips)
"Randall is the best server on Duval."(3 Tips)
"Caribbean steak is flipping delicious!!!"(2 Tips)
"The Key West lemonade was awesome, and we got the nicest service."(2 Tips)
89 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- dolphin fingers
- sandwiches
- casual
- good for groups
- key west lemonade
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Robert AmezquitaAugust 14, 2014Key like pie and salads on a hot day. Yellowfin salad is like. Wow. Close to all the little shops - look for Key West mini surfboards decor!
Allyson HamiltonNovember 28, 2012Best prices on Duval! Food was great and huge lunch portions! Conch Fritters....not so much. Service was awesome and the Manager came around to thank everyone for their business. Class act!Upvoted Dec 6, 2024
Jen GrisellJuly 10, 2013Maple and Bacon salad is incredible... Service was great! And the owner came by to check on us and even gave us a little tip on how to make the maple bacon salad at home!!
Al Gonzalez Tax Professional & RealtorJanuary 18, 2015So far #great #service and great #drinks, looking forward to great #food at reasonable #prices
Naveen ApApril 19, 2014The black chicken pasta and the Caribbean steak are worth coming for again ... Amazing stuff and the waiter, Allison was super Awesome too :)
William R J RibeiroMay 16, 2015No airco for a change but it doesn't mean the place is too warm. The chicken is as good as it gets and the banana is superb.
Marcel P.November 24, 2014The burger is huge and good. Fair prices, friendly staff. My golden margarita was too salty though
Quentin HqOctober 22, 2015Salad macon & bacon / caesar are delicious. Soft drinks free refill. Not expensive
Joe GalentineSeptember 14, 2014Great place to go. Have a meal or just sit at the bar and people watch. Both food and staff are great.- Kristin BrooksNovember 4, 2013Delicious food. The Key West lemonade was awesome, and we got the nicest service. Very pleased with our lunch here.
KathyMay 22, 2014Great food with al fresco seating including chickens roaming and begging for snacks! Loved the seared tuna and the daily catch. Friendly and entertaining.
Caroline's never disappoints. Great food and great people. One of my favorites is the salad deluxe!
Courtney AlundJune 14, 2013Always amazing food!! The Macon and Bacon salad is amazing! A mouthful of different flavors....love love love!
Pierre BJanuary 1, 2014I have had a lot of Cajun chicken sandwiches but this one was easily the best.
Heather MMay 2, 2014My least favorite place I've been to in Key West so far. It's not terrible. A little overpriced but not incredibly so (as most things are in KW) for what they serve. Enjoyed the outdoor seating.
Joe TaulbeeJuly 27, 2013Without question, the best bruschetta I've ever had... And that's coming from an Italian
Lauren AikenSeptember 2, 2012Blackened chicken pasta is spicy but good! Dolphin sandwich is also tasty.
Janis DeedyJanuary 14, 2013The fish sandwich is ah-may-zing. Crispy on the outside and flaky on the inside! Love it!!!!
Jenn TofanelliApril 5, 2012Lettuce wrap salad. Or order the cheese steak except with chicken. Super delish. And fantastic people watching.
Gisele DreesbachJune 1, 2014Believe the comment about the macon & bacon salad. It is surprisingly delicious
Ashley SApril 12, 2013Bloody Mary was meh, conch fritters with spicy mayo sauce and fried mahi mahi sammich was phenomenal!!!
PaulAugust 4, 2011Cuban Press is decent and cheap. Nothing life changing, but cheap for Duval St. and great people watching (especially from the bar). Cops eat here, so it must be decent.
Paul ENovember 22, 2011Could be me, but are all resort towns stuck somewhere btwn 1975 and 1988? Nice place, good service. Don't forget your "keep on truckin'" ringer tee.
William StephensAugust 18, 2012The food here makes The Cheesecake Factory look like Applebee's. The jambalaya and blackened chicken entrees are fucking fantastic.
345 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–11:30 PM
(305) 294-7511
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Caroline's Cafe
Appears on 70 lists
Created by Kino
230 items • 2 followers
Key West - Favorite Restarants/Eats
Created by Mike Drasher
22 items • 7 followersKey West - Favorite Watering Holes
Created by Mike Drasher
12 items • 6 followers
