See all
618 photos

Cafe Fiorello

Italian Restaurant, Pizzeria, and Breakfast Spot$$$$

Lincoln Square, New York

Save

Cafe Fiorello

7.9^/10

447

ratings

Ranked #8 for Italian restaurants in the Upper West Side
The folks at The New York Times and Serious Eats like this place. Would you agree?
"Always great at Lincoln Center"(4 Tips)
"The fried artichokes are GREAT!"(5 Tips)
"Margherita Pizza and Chocolate Mousse = perfection"(10 Tips)
"Amazing thin crust pizzas - the meat supreme is out of this world."(6 Tips)

134 Tips and reviews

Filter:

lincoln center
chocolate mousse
good for dates
desserts
fried artichokes
good for groups
lemoncello tart
brunch food
cookies
muffins
pancakes
salads
bar
Aperol Spritz
scenic views
meringues
breakfast food
outdoor seating
cake
dinner
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Kelly CJune 9, 2014
This place is so cute. Overlooks Lincoln Center, get a seat outside. Weekday lunch special $27.50 for an app & entree. Caprese salad, spinach pesto pappardelle, and lump crab cake 👌
Upvoted Dec 13, 2024
Bev WrightJune 13, 2017
Salmon Eggs Benedict had whole slices of salmon, perfect hollandaise. Applewood bacon served 6 slices, perfectly cooked. Quiet Tuesday morning, lovely music, attentive service. A favorite!
Upvoted Jan 10
Ms HeleneJune 20, 2015
Antipasto selection large but get the eggplant caponata as 1 of 3 for $22 or $10 each. House made bread basket included great focaccia. Poached 1lb lobster salad with farro $38. Thin crust pizza.
Upvoted Dec 31, 2024
El Greco Jakob Instagram @coach.jakobOctober 8, 2024
Been here 10+ times
Once again at this amazing place Cafe Fiorello 50yrs in business one of the best Italian of all time. Great food fantastic service, elegant. Yum 😋 antipastos, da truffle pizza is amazing 🙌🏼
Meg FarmerDecember 18, 2014
Across from lincoln center, eat at the bar before a show. Order a pizza & build a plate from all the fresh veggies they have on display. Asparagus & fava beans are delicious. Service is excellent.
El Greco Jakob Instagram @coach.jakobOctober 8, 2024
Been here 10+ times
Such great place, fantastic food and amazing service. And not as expensive like other Italian restaurants which are 50% as good as cafe fiorello 🙌🏼
Emil HAugust 12, 2018
The lasagna is served open-face and is delicious.
stephani szokeSeptember 29, 2013
Sit at the bar for the best experience at Cafe Fiorello. We havrnt had a bad bartender. Thy are great and the food is amazing. Try the 3 seafood plate. They plate it right at the bar.
Martin HurstSeptember 8, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Amazing thin crust pizzas - the meat supreme is out of this world. And the antipasto bar is full of amazing dishes: shrimp and scallop salad, lentil salad, burrata, roasted fennel. It's all amazing!
El Greco Jakob Instagram @coach.jakobOctober 27, 2018
Been here 10+ times
It’s always a pleasure dinner/time at Fiorello’s. With fun great service and superb food how possibly not be the best place.
Paula BuzzoFebruary 26, 2023
Avocado toast with poached egg comes with salad and fries. Delicious food, excellent prices and awesome service.
Lee HoffmanOctober 14, 2021
Incredible chicken pepperoni parm and the BEST chocolate mousse and whip cream I’ve ever had
Vee BeeFebruary 12, 2013
This 'open faced' lasagne is everything other 4sq tippers have said. It's a must! You'll be disappointed if you don't order this. Incredible! If only it can vegetarian too....
Andrea HongFebruary 24, 2013
First, make an opentable res bc this place is a Lincoln Center zoo. Then, get poured champagne upon arrival, fed passed freshly baked cookies, and stuffed on thin crust pizza (prosciutto + arugula!).
Parin LadOctober 29, 2018
The lasagne was very special - totally different to any I’ve seen before! Good range of salads too. Craft IPA on tap was good too.
Mark BOctober 14, 2018
Delicious food, attentive wait staff & reasonably priced. Go when the weather is warm to take advantage of outside seating!
Kevin StappDecember 26, 2018
Artichoke starter and Truffle Ravioli were delicious. Chocolate Mousse and whipped cream served out the bucket at our table was truly decadent!
William CJuly 10, 2019
Excellent food. I had the seafood risotto it was great!!! My wife had the Rigatoni w/Vodka sauce she loved it.
Marie La RueSeptember 15, 2018
Extensive Italian menu for the whole family. Good stop for dinner pre or post theatre. Antipasti bar with many vegetarian options.
Teresa Weaver MilnerAugust 14, 2013
The lemon torte is good. The bread is fantastic. It's neat that they walk thru the restaurant offering random fresh baked muffins and cookies.
Nation's Restaurant NewsAugust 5, 2013
Naked ravioli. This gluten-free, low-carb dish by executive chef Brando d’Oliveira is his version of gnudi, or ricotta dumplings. Read more
The Corcoran GroupNovember 1, 2011
Once you step inside you’ll be treated like an A-Lister – the service is that good. Then just try and finish the Double Pepperoni & Baby Arugula Thin Crust Pizza.
Daniel SilvermanAugust 25, 2013
Honestly incredible. Service ON POINT. Food fresh, creative and succulent. Highly. I would highly Recommend Fiorellio to nearly everyone.
DCCARGUY William HopperDecember 9, 2011
Just because it is full of people at the door does not mean you will not get seated quickly. Work your way to the host stand and give them your name. You will be surprised how fast you get seated!
Trae FOctober 8, 2018
The pizza is excellent and love sitting at the bar chatting w the friendly bartenders
Sergey ShashkinDecember 16, 2014
Lasagnia is an introduction to Heaven of Italian cuisine. Go for Valppolichella Ripasso. To make your day Italian way.
💎TFebruary 23, 2015
Came here with my dad and we shared a margherita pizza and an arugula salad. Just amazing !
Serious EatsFebruary 1, 2012
from a pizza-hunter's perspective, we think what Fiorello is good for is eating some good, very thin crust pies on a nice day outside before a show. Read more
MëlänïMarch 18, 2017
The spaghetti carbonara was on point. The guys at he second bar finished us off with a little limoncello.
Adam ClewleyAugust 29, 2015
Only here for drinks. Best Aperol Spritz I've had in NYC. Food all looked delicious.
Liza DavydovaApril 28, 2016
The calamari is amazing! The Italian wedding soup is a must have!
El Greco Jakob Instagram @coach.jakobJune 24, 2018
Been here 10+ times
Best Italian food in nyc!!!
Emil HAugust 31, 2019
You’ve never had lasagna like this. Don’t miss out.
Adam NowickiSeptember 30, 2013
Great service grilled veggies are just phenomenal not my first time and will be back for sure !
Ruth SarfatyApril 27, 2015
Great post movie dinner. Quiet table in back. Polenta was delicious. Eggplant parm larg or small.
Kira Garvin LermanJuly 17, 2014
Vegan friendly seitan options! Definitely try the fried artichokes when they are in season.
Drew TabuAugust 28, 2010
Best lasagna anywhere. We like to get a selection of antipasti (including the fried artichoke for sure!) and then share the lasagna between two (even three).
Szoke SteveJune 2, 2013
Very cool place! Sit at the bar, the tenders will entertain. ... sit outside, the people will entertain.
Lee HoffmanJune 2, 2013
The chicken pepperoni Parmesan is delicious and huge. Past not included tho.
SaraMarch 23, 2013
Try to get a booth; not as cramped. Make sure to save room for dessert. The meringue cake is to die for.
Meredith PharisNovember 24, 2013
This place was fabulous and all we had was antipasti! Will be back for more.
Lockhart SteeleOctober 18, 2023
Straight classic, thin crust pizza and antipasto and repeat for the next 59 years.
Samantha ManganaroJune 7, 2013
Really delicious! And they had a vegan soup! The caramelized fennel was amazing.
El Greco Jakob Instagram @coach.jakobOctober 27, 2018
Been here 10+ times
Best Italian restaurant in town. And the service, superb.!
Christopher FredaJanuary 15, 2020
The lasagna and veal chop parmigiana are incredible!
Michel BiquardSeptember 4, 2018
Great food and service. Chocolate mousse is a must.
Alina CJuly 7, 2013
Great food and when everyone got out of the oven chocolate chip cookies samples we were hooked!
Jeff SolomonJanuary 29, 2019
Try the pizza with pepperoni, arugula, and burrata cheese
William NelliganAugust 10, 2014
These guys pass around a lot of good (free) snacks on the weekend.
Amy SagarAugust 20, 2018
The lasagna is amazing and big enough to share!

1 2 3

618 Photos

Cafe Fiorello

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Cafe Fiorello

Appears on 278 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.