Butter & Scotch
(Now Closed)Cocktail Bar and Bakery$$$$
Crown Heights, Brooklyn
86 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Gabriel HayesAugust 21, 2015The Pop Up restaurant nights are awesome. At the Peach Pit dinner, loved the Long Island Scallop Crudo (made with sandita, peach nectar granita & yuzukosho).
Cole KennedyJune 22, 2015After you've knocked back a Disco Nap, try the Honeychile Rider, with gin, passion fruit, lemon, spicy honey, and tiki bitters. Exotic and delicious!
- Gabriel HayesAugust 21, 2015At the Pop Up dinners, Butter & Scotch does flavor paired drinks and desserts. At the Peach Pit dinner, got the 'Fuck the Pain Away' to drink. An awesome drink that is strong but goes down so smooth.
- Gabriel HayesAugust 21, 2015At the Peach Pit dinner, they had a Chocolate Peach Melba that was phenomenal. Made with Chipotle Brownie, Vanilla Ice Cream and Peach & Raspberry Compote.
- Gabriel HayesAugust 21, 2015At the Peach Pit dinner, had the Peach Shortcake for dessert and loved it. Made with Butter Biscuit, Peach Compote and Vanilla Whip. So tasty.
Hannah DMarch 4, 2016Honeychile cocktail was out of this world, and the birthday cake ($6 for an ENORMOUS slice) was amazing. Loved it, and will definitely be back.
Mitra SalaselSeptember 14, 2017Get the birthday cake, any number of excellently themed cocktails, and the nachos after you've had a few cocktails. Avoid the cheese puffs, waaay too salty.
- Gabriel HayesAugust 21, 2015The Honeychile Rider is my favorite cocktail. Made with Dorothy Parker Gin, Passion Fruit Puree, Mike's Hot Honey, Lemon and Bittermens Tiki Bitters
- Gabriel HayesJanuary 25, 2016Butter & Scotch celebrated its 1 Year Birthday on January 24th. Had a special 50% off Make It Sparkle (Birthday Cake and Bubbly). Congrats to them on one year!
The New YorkerMarch 30, 2015“The owners, Keavy Blueher and Allison Kave, are straight out of your indie-movie dreams—drunken pixie dream ladies serving up s’mores pie and jello shots.” Read more
- Gabriel HayesAugust 21, 2015Keep your eye open for the Pop Up Restaurant nights. Went to the BigLittle Get Together's Peach Dinner and had a great time.
Marie RicherDecember 6, 2016When you walk in it smells like the most delicious bakery. Drinks and desserts are good and it has a really nice warm vibe.
Joanna FlammAugust 24, 2017Basically a perfect date night: wine and pie! Vibe is very woman-friendly; I'd feel safe sitting alone at the bar here.
- Gabriel HayesMarch 29, 2015The Union Street Collins is a delicious cocktail. Made with Reyka Vodka, hibiscus, clove, lemon, aromatic bitters & seltzer.
LukeSeptember 12, 2015Dessert? Booze? Both together in several amazing combinations? I approve of this concept and seeing it executed so well makes me happy
Maxwell FoxmanJune 14, 2016Great dessert-y cocktails but also great caramel corn like Green Chile Margarita.- Cole KennedyJune 22, 2015Start with the Disco Nap: a shot of coffee-infused reposado tequila with a splash of amaro that WILL wake you up.
Brittany GalskeDecember 22, 2019bought this cake for my friends on their 21st bday! let me say i don’t like chocolate cake but this cake was something else! best cakes in brooklyn!
Larisa GrollemondJanuary 27, 2015s'mores pie is worth braving the crowd at this brand new cocktails and dessert spot. a welcome addition to the neighborhood!
Jenny CrowleyJuly 30, 2016Happy birthday cake to me! Friendly staff. Lots of deliciously sinful treats. As Mary Berry would say--scrummy!
This place should not be marked with 3 $... You can buy many items on their menu under $10. To me, that is cheap and affordable for any bar in the area.
- S'more pie. Many items under $10. White Russian 'Milk' & Cookies...Strong addition to the neighborhood.
Christopher AshleyMarch 17, 2017The Hotline bling chocolate cake was great! Eager to try more desserts
Kimmie OhhAugust 15, 2020They serve blue marble ice cream & boozy shakes. You must try their Jell-O shots!
AngieOctober 1, 2017Everything is amazing! Hotline bling cake, the white russian, Madonna-Rihanna-Ilana cocktail, Sandsnakes. Love this place
TV Food MapsFebruary 22, 2015Check out Butter and Scotch as it was featured on Unique Sweets for old-fashioned pies and quenching cocktails collide with delicious results Read more
CharlottesSeptember 19, 2017Stunning and delicious cakes and fabulous staff. Can't wait to chill at the bar
Patrick BaskinJanuary 19, 2016Cocktails + dessert = fantastic idea & they fulfilled 100%, get the s'mores pie for sure
Joslyn HansenMay 11, 2018Great cocktails, and delicious key lime pie. The birthday cake is perhaps over-hyped.
Eric EmanuelsonJanuary 29, 2020Fun spot for a drink with friends or date. Desert drinks are (you guessed it) sweet
Zack SheppardMarch 13, 2015The s'more pie is so much more than you think a s'more pie can be. You need to get it.
Julie AvraJune 4, 2017This place is so cute and the birthday cake is amazing. Really dense and delicious- Gabriel HayesMarch 29, 2015Awesome new place on Franklin Ave in Crown Heights. Cool bar with awesome desserts.
Olivia AAugust 4, 2015The Pineapple drink has a legit skewer of ham in it as a garnish. It's delightful.
Trina CJanuary 25, 2017Went there 2 celebrate my bday & theirs.Would post a pic of the bday cake if they ever served me!!! Me & my date sat for 10 mins .Another cpl came in right NEXT 2 us & they were served right away!
"Try dunking that cookie in your White Russian" is the best advice I've had all week.
199 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Butter & Scotch is a bar & bakery specializing in creative riffs on classic American desserts and craft cocktails.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon
- 5:00 PM–Midnight
- Tue–Fri
- 9:00 AM–Midnight
- Sat–Sun
- 10:00 AM–2:00 AM
(347) 350-8899
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dessert, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Butter & Scotch
Appears on 578 lists
Created by Paul O.
243 items • 18 followers
Created by Justin P
212 items • 19 followers
Created by Zak Accuardi
130 items • 23 followers