Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Montauk
Herb's Market is one of Montauk.

1. Herb's Market

7.6
778 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY
Deli · 23 tips and reviews

naveennaveen: fried chicken fried chicken get it take it outside and eat on the sidewalk bench

2. South Edison

7.4
17 S Edison St (Montauk Highway), Montauk, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 61 tips and reviews

Katie S.Katie Schloss: Not great for big parties, so grab two stools at the bar, and order the whole menu. Seriously. Kale salad, octopus tacos, oysters... A definite Montauk favorite.

3. La Brisa

752 Montauk Hwy (The plaza), Montauk, NY
Taco Restaurant · 30 tips and reviews

Ellie R.Ellie Rountree: Same owners as Tacombi in Nolita. Love the tacos and make sure to get a beer with breakfast. It's the only way to start your Saturday!

4. John's Drive-In

8.1
677 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · 58 tips and reviews

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Burgers, shakes and fries and the best homemade ice cream to boot! Try the John burger and the homemade ice cream. No website, but then who needs one for a popular place like this.

5. Montauk Brewing Company

9.2
62 S Erie Ave, Montauk, NY
Brewery · 39 tips and reviews

Barbara G.Barbara Gavin: Due to bizarre liquor regulations...you buy an $8 tasting, giving you 4 five ounce tastes, plus the glass. You can also buy a growler, for off premises consumption.

6. Scarpetta Beach

8.0
290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY
Italian Restaurant · 13 tips and reviews

Anuj M.Anuj Mathur: a long cocktail bar with plenty of seating. two small tables with two chairs overlook the bar. there's two comfy couches at the back as well which often get overlooked.

The Inlet Seafood Restaurant is one of Montauk.

7. The Inlet Seafood Restaurant

7.6
541 E Lake Dr, Montauk, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 45 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: Dine on Inlet Seafood's deck within view of narrow waterways, open sea and distant coastlines. At this restaurant, freshness of seafood -- sushi included -- is paramount. Read more.

8. Zum Schneider MTK

4 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY
German Restaurant · 21 tips and reviews

Michael T.Michael Thiele: I'm rarely excited by some NYC restaurant opening an outpost out here, but I was ecstatic when I heard about Zum Schneider. Just fantastic, authentic food and beer in an unpretentious atmosphere.

9. Red Hook Lobster MTK

34 S Etna Ave (btwn S Edison & S Essex St), Montauk, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 9 tips and reviews

Marc K.Marc Krohn: Get The Monteith for breakfast - a lobster roll with egg, bacon, fontina cheese and spinach for only $12. It was easily one of the best things I ate in Montauk

10. Joni's

8.1
28 S Etna Ave, Montauk, NY
Sandwich Spot · 69 tips and reviews

Shannon V.Shannon Vittoria: Great spot for breakfast with a very west coast vibe and great California cuisine (& plenty health-conscious options). Highly recommend the flax coconut waffle. Great tea selection too.

11. Gosman's Restaurant

7.6
500 W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 52 tips and reviews

ToryBurchToryBurch: About 30 minutes from East Hampton- Montauk is well-worth the trip. After enjoying fresh from the sea lobsters, and views from the peaceful dock at Gosman's Restaurant.

Harvest on Fort Pond is one of Montauk.

12. Harvest on Fort Pond

8.4
11 S Emery St (S Euclid Ave), Montauk, NY
Mediterranean Restaurant · 65 tips and reviews

HarryHarry: Everything was great! The watercress, the sea bass, and definitely the ice cream sandwich are all very recommended! Service was excellent too! Arrive before sunset see the view from the pier!

13. The Surf Lodge

7.4
183 S Edgemere St, Montauk, NY
Hotel · 89 tips and reviews

Lindsay G.Lindsay Grenawalt: enjoy the eye-candy of men wearing checker on checker. omg. another dude in salmon colored shorts. hawt.

14. Ruschmeyer's

6.9
161 Second House Rd, Montauk, NY
Hotel · 49 tips and reviews

Travel + LeisureTravel + Leisure: A summer camp for grown-ups in Montauk. Think cabins clustered around a decorative tepee, bingo nights, Ping-Pong, and a bar in an oversize sandbox.

Happy Bowls is one of Montauk.

15. Happy Bowls

7.0
805 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY
Juice Bar · 13 tips and reviews

HarryHarry: Great way to start your day! Or replenish energy and nutrients after a morning run ;) Try the 500 calorie bowl and add coconut flakes and toasted cashew nuts!

16. Melet Mercantile

Industrial road, Montauk, NY
Antique Store · 1 tip

Travel + LeisureTravel + Leisure: In an unassuming Montauk garage, Bob Melet—former director of vintage buying at Ralph Lauren—displays used surfboards, 1970’s rock concert T-shirts, and other offbeat discoveries.

Whalebone Creative is one of Montauk.

17. Whalebone Creative

7.3
65 Tuthill Rd, Montauk, NY
Clothing Store · 1 tip

18. Clam & Chowder House

7.1
470 W Lake Dr (Salivar's Dock), Montauk, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 2 tips and reviews

Consuelo R.Consuelo Ruybal: We had the Clams Casino 👍🏽 and the daily catch oysters. Everything was really good. The bartender was a hoot. It's a fun, no nonsense kind of joint.

19. Duryea's Lobster Deck & Seafood Market

8.2
65 Tuthill Rd, Montauk, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 60 tips and reviews

Travel + LeisureTravel + Leisure: Bring a bottle of rosé to Duryea’s, set on a rocky Montauk outcropping and renowned for its well-priced lobster. Just be prepared for a long wait.

20. Montauket

8.8
88 Firestone Rd, Montauk, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 30 tips and reviews

HeatherHeather: Waterfront backyard makes this place a prime spot for sunsets and outdoor drinking. It offers Montauk Brewing Co. on draft, Wölffer Estate rosé, and daily drink specials (often made with rum).

21. Navy Beach Restaurant

7.7
16 Navy Rd (Shore Road), Montauk, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 85 tips and reviews

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Come here early to claim a table, and stick around until sunset while enjoying the rose sangria and lobster ceviche.