See all
85 photos

Bonfyre American Grille

American Restaurant and Cocktail Bar$$$$

Madison

Save

7.5^/10

149

ratings

"The cure and ice bloody Mary is very good but it's huge!"(4 Tips)
"Try Mort's Pot Roast; you will be glad that you did."(6 Tips)
"Best margaritas in town."(2 Tips)
"Steak and eggs"(2 Tips)

35 Tips and reviews

Filter:

seafood
butternut squash soup
margaritas
great value
trendy
tequila
good for groups
pork tenderloin
French toast
pot roast
brunch food
dinner
coconut
curry
meats
lunch
parking
mango
organic
watermelon
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Bill FleckSeptember 20, 2013
Best margaritas in town. Try a choice of regular organic, watermelon, mango or jalapeño spiced all made with this new great tequila. Tres Agaves.
Joe LongApril 28, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Up until my last experience here id have told you the service was excellent. Hopefully they were just having an off day as I do truly enjoy this place. Great ahi tuna salad, good location. Good soup.
Joanna PoeJune 12, 2022
Attended a private party in the back; all the food was great and the service was awesome.
Danny RFebruary 28, 2012
This place is a must try for Sunday brunch. Steak and eggs, french toast and bloody Mary's are the best you'll ever have!
Eric LarsonSeptember 24, 2010
Been here 10+ times
While the atmosphere is wonderful and the service is great, when there are two of you ordering any kind of steaks, make sure that you order the same "doneness" else you might be sending a plate back.
Gerrit MarshallMarch 6, 2016
Great! Excellent service and the meal is wonderful. Cocktails👍
Matthew TaubDecember 20, 2015
Good consistent suburbs place. They have good healthy options and a solid beer list.
Tyler HolleJuly 29, 2015
Get the sweet potato fries as a side - they're cinnamon sprinkled deliciousness!
Jaime GarbischJanuary 9, 2015
Food, service and the old fashioneds were all outstanding
Joshua B.March 3, 2014
Mort's Pot Roast is awesome! Try the Curry and Coconut Mussels too!
Steph ByrnesMarch 4, 2011
The cure and ice bloody Mary is very good but it's huge! I ended up getting another glass to give my husband half.
Maria MorrisMarch 18, 2011
Been here 10+ times
The pizzas are delicious, esp the Thai chicken. Great craft beer and good wine selection too.
France ChampassakSeptember 21, 2011
Definitely, go to culvers or KFC-DRIVE THRU over this place. You will know what I'm talking bout, once you've wasted 45min of your life in there. No eye candy at the door either. Yikes
Lover FaceSeptember 21, 2011
As a matter of fact, as u sit here the suckiness is almost overwhelming. At lease I'm with the love of my life. Thanks France, we'll just hate it together.
Jessica SasApril 28, 2012
Amazing food! Have the bloody Mary! Best in all of madison!
Sarah PhillipsJanuary 18, 2012
We love the BBQ chicken and the pot roast! Our favorite date :)
Lysa GrantMarch 3, 2016
12.00 lunch? You betcha !
Ben GieseMarch 3, 2012
Love the Pork Tenderloin dish and Batch 19 beer!!!
Holly RingleOctober 23, 2014
Great pot roast soup
eliNovember 26, 2018
WiFi password: Bonfyre2601
Jacob TorgesonMarch 5, 2012
Large bill for a small meal.. Tastes alright depending on what u get.. This place could be a lot better if they gave u larger portions or lowered the bill... I don't wanna pay for the atmosphere...
Gerrit MarshallMarch 6, 2016
Make reservations.
Tracey ZieglerNovember 16, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Love Bonfyre's pot roast. Find a $10 gift card on thecommunitychange.com.
Linda KleinschmidtMarch 31, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Love the butternut squash soup
rachaelDecember 31, 2011
Sign up for their emails get a free appitizer
Linda KleinschmidtAugust 17, 2013
Been here 5+ times
The waitstaff rocks!!!!!!!
MaureenAugust 3, 2013
Enjoyed the California Turkey Burger.
Carrie KlickoFebruary 6, 2010
Very pretty, great atmosphere to gather after work and have a martini Read more
Sean KippermanMarch 10, 2010
Been here 100+ times
Have the "Fyre and Ice" signature bloody mary; it is wonderous to behold.
Sean KippermanMarch 10, 2010
Been here 100+ times
Try Mort's Pot Roast; you will be glad that you did.
TerrenceJanuary 15, 2011
you only get 2 crabcakes.. fyi
Ryan WJune 6, 2010
Have to try the Irish Margarita
Jessica MorrisonMarch 8, 2010
Go to Bonfyre. The pot roast is divine.
Blake RobertsonNovember 4, 2011
New, shiny. All hype, no quality. Small entrees, small tap list, bad service. No reason to waste your time.
Lover FaceSeptember 21, 2011
It sucked!

85 Photos

Bonfyre American Grille

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Bonfyre American Grille

Appears on 33 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.