Between the Bun - Burgers, Dogs and More
(Now Closed)Burger Joint$$$$
Indianapolis
29 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Paula SmithApril 28, 2013I had the pulled pork sandwich with the SUGR BBQ sauce with Fries. Loved it all. Hubby had the Route 66 burger with Mac and Cheese. Wont the Mac and Cheese again but will so get the burger again.
I love the Route 66 & the Mac Daddy, but you can't go wrong anywhere on the menu. Everything is delicious. The burger sampler is great. My sister & I shared so we could try several different burgers.
Best locally owned burger joint in the Greater Indianapolis area. Scott is friendly & is always trying new concept burgers. You HAVE to try the Caramel Apple Burger! Best Burgers and the Best People!
Everything on the menu is better than good the owner is great the staff is fun. They go out if their way to make the meal the best of your day
The PB&J burger is amazing! The amount of PB on this, along with the bacon...so awesome! The staff is awesome as well! You can't go wrong with any of the food
Between the Bun - Burgers, Dogs and MoreMay 9, 2014Chris Kauffman, we never claimed to be the first to put peanut butter on a burger but we do claim to do it the best. As for your boycotting our restaurant, that is completely your decision.
Jasmine StoneJuly 11, 2015I had the Spitfire Ranch Burger....very good, nice cozy atmosphere with great deals and great food...
So the sauce in question is awesome! Just get over the name, come here & get it! If it were crappy, then maybe...but it's very tasty! Really all the BBQ sauces are!
John KirtlandApril 1, 2013Restaurant is based on the Between the Bun food truck. Great staff and great decor. Music is casual and good.
Michael HumphreyFebruary 13, 2015some of the best fries ive ever had. try the Notorious P.I.G. or if your really hungry take on the big pig challenge.
Christopher KauffmanMay 6, 2014So they have peanut butter on a burger ? Well XXX Family restaurant in West Lafayette has that too. Difference is XXX had it first. Dont believe me look it up
Robert WilsonSeptember 11, 2015Amazing food and our waitress was the best. My family and I loved everything about between the bun.- Between the Bun - Burgers, Dogs and MoreMay 9, 2014I am sure if you knew all the details you would feel differently. But thanks for stopping by our Foursquare!! We appreciate your feedback.
Mark WaldronJune 18, 2017More miss than hit. Been here 4 times, hoping for a win, only once satisfied. 6 min before being waited on, 28 min before getting just 2 burgers. Tried Thai One On, no clue why it's "award winning".- The burgers here are amazing! Pig Pen quesadilla is awesome and the service is excellent! Plus, it's locally owned and operated!
- Scott has done it again! "The Pigpen Quesadilla" is a must! Make sure you get here today!
Halie DeutschNovember 22, 2014Their hotdogs are amazing! I would recommend trying one! #hotdogs I got the BLT hotdog!
Steve SmithAugust 23, 2013Upon reading these other comments and comparing them to my own experience, I'm wondering how many were written by the owner or someone connected to him. Quality of food was questionable.
Shelley Liford SellersAugust 17, 2013Had the steak house burger, it was awesome. Husband had the PB&J, delicious- Can't go wrong with the nacho or Italian stallion burgers! And the onion rings rock!
- Christopher KauffmanMay 6, 2014By the way after reading the owners response. You have lost a customer, as well as the rest of my friends we will boycott your place.
- John KirtlandApril 3, 2013Boss Hog is a solid burger. Spitfire Chili Fries are pretty solid as well.
- Between the Bun - Burgers, Dogs and MoreAugust 23, 2013Steve S. we do not need to "pad" our reviews. Your reviews on Urbanspoon and Yelp are completely fabricated. Find something else to do. Our food speaks for itself. Bye now.
33 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Between the Bun - Burgers, Dogs and More
102 S Madison Ave (Main St.)
Indianapolis, IN 46142
United States
Indianapolis, IN 46142
United States
Located in Old Town Greenwood at 102 S. Madison Ave, we are bringing you Indy's best specialty burgers and dogs and a few other things too.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Tue–Thu
- 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Sun
- Noon–9:00 PM
(317) 300-8327
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
Yes
Parking
Street, Public Lot, Private Lot
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Between the Bun - Burgers, Dogs and More
Appears on 8 lists
Naptown's absolute best burger and hot dog spots.
Created by Qatadah Nasaaj
99 items • 4 followers
Created by Ryan Austill
71 items
Created by Robert Donovan
183 items