See all
381 photos

Benjamin Steakhouse

Steakhouse$$$$

Midtown East, New York

Save

Benjamin Steakhouse

8.8^/10

421

ratings

Ranked #8 for steakhouses in New York
"this is the best...hands down best...steak house in NYC"(2 Tips)
"... – get the potatoes and creamed spinach. Finish with the apple strudel."(3 Tips)
"second visit at this cozy Midtown steakhouse."(2 Tips)
"Try the Rib Eye! Amazing with the fries!"(7 Tips)

85 Tips and reviews

Filter:

steak
good for dates
creamed spinach
good for groups
filet mignon
trendy
cheesecake
breakfast food
wedge salad
bar
potatoes
bacon
pancakes
dinner
good for special occasions
good for business meetings
porterhouse
alcohol
soup
crowded
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

The Corcoran GroupNovember 1, 2011
A gorgeously decorated steakhouse (very warm and traditional) serving perhaps the best porterhouse in NYC – get the potatoes and creamed spinach. Finish with the apple strudel.
Halstead PropertyJuly 11, 2013
A classic, succulent filet mignon with a side of creamed spinach is just the right combination of meat and greens to leave us satisfied and ready for a second visit at this cozy Midtown steakhouse.
Upvoted Jan 1
DFebruary 11, 2016
Crab cake & Canadian bacon to start and then the main entrees were Porterhouse for two and creamless cream spinach. Everything was delicious! Tiramisu for dessert was mediocre.
Upvoted Dec 31, 2024
What's Good HereApril 17, 2015
For sides, start with the spinach and Benjamin home fries. Ask for the fries to be done crisp for some caramelized onion goodness.
Emma SnyderJuly 10, 2016
The steak and lamb here is perfect. I recommend the cheesecake as well :) I will definitely be revisiting!
Francis UdlerOctober 15, 2014
Great service and steak. Steak was perfectly cooked and the right amount of salty. Get the mashed potatoes.
BassimDecember 6, 2014
Crab cakes, calamari, salmon, and ribeye steak were my dishes. Everything was delicious.
Brian ChaseOctober 9, 2013
Come here when someone else is paying. You'll enjoy the amazing steaks more.
Nitzan BDecember 29, 2016
The meat was amazing and service was spectacular! Must go for all meat lovers
Benjamin CoatsJune 24, 2016
Very good. Best wedge salad in the city and the steak is nice as well.
Aurélie J.January 20, 2014
Waouuuuuh the steak for three is just AMAZING! Take the Benjamin Home Fries to go with it...
Yaz SAugust 10, 2019
Split a salad, porterhouse, and mashed potatoes for two. Amazing 😋🥩
The Journal News/LoHud.comJune 13, 2011
The mouth-watering menu at Benjamin Steakhouse comes to no surprise. Porterhouse, ribeyes and filet mignon meals are all dry-aged in their huge aging box. Read more
Wendell RobinsonJanuary 11, 2012
Ribeye steak was amazingly good. Well cooked, juicy and flavorful. Took all my self restraint not to gnaw on the bone
Barbara MestreJune 27, 2015
Amaaazing! Get the ny sirloin and the mushrooms. To DIE for.
unknownJuly 21, 2019
The best fillet mignon! amazing staff. totally recommended
YNNovember 5, 2016
Surprisingly tender. Great atmosphere.
EllaOctober 27, 2016
Pleasant place perfect steak and the best mashed potatous!
Kyle WilsonJanuary 27, 2016
Shrimp cocktail followed by the steak
CarolynJanuary 24, 2015
The steak for two is stellar.
Kelsey P.June 25, 2012
There thing is STEAK. I admit, the sides are not wowing, but I go there for meat. And it is heaven.
E BJanuary 4, 2013
Great steak but a bit overcooked. Service is great and desserts were awesome.
DFebruary 11, 2016
The main dining area from above
Anne KuttererAugust 20, 2013
The wait was not great but the food was amazing!!!!!! Totally worth the wait!!!
Carole NicholsApril 25, 2019
Food was excellent! Amazing steak.
Barbara BilodeauSeptember 30, 2016
The Lobster Bisque is delicious!
Ally TropsaJuly 26, 2014
Severely underrated! Best steak in nyc!
Hunter ThomasApril 2, 2015
Great steak options and seating for large groups. Pricey.
Arlene Aran AmaranteDecember 24, 2011
They say it is as good as Peter Luger since the chef used to work for Peter Luger. Must reserve.
Cindy OlSeptember 12, 2014
Great clubby atmosphere and service
Jessica S.October 4, 2011
One of my favorite restaurants! Service is great, and the steaks cut like butter.
Arlene Aran AmaranteDecember 24, 2011
They age their beef. Very good indeed! Must try when in NY!
Meghan MJune 1, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Simply the best!! Better than all the rest!
Benjamin SteakhouseNovember 21, 2013
Featured today in IN NewYork for our Thanksgiving Day Menu! Read more
GabrielJuly 30, 2013
Try the Rib Eye! Amazing with the fries!
ToritoooSeptember 30, 2018
Just the bar. But everything was terrible, I ask for well done meat... this was their deliver...so sadly. The price and quality doesn't work
Joe CalderoneDecember 3, 2016
Steak for 2 for 1!
Albert SzeJanuary 28, 2013
porter house was fantastic and the bacon was glorious
Barbara MestreJune 27, 2015
Sirloin and mushrooms. Trust me.
Metin HulluFebruary 1, 2013
Get the steak for 2.. Insanely delicious!
Larry BodineAugust 30, 2013
Awesome steakhouse, knowledgeable waiters
Luis Guillermo LeonApril 16, 2018
Steak for two! Delicious.
Snooply 57December 14, 2013
Reservation at 8 pm; 25 mins later we are still waiting for a table
TrevorJuly 26, 2017
A classic midtown steakhouse
Bora KocyigitJanuary 3, 2016
The definition of awesomeness : Rib Eye
PHDJuly 31, 2012
"Cooked perfectly. Juicy, flavorful, seared and tender" -UrbanSpoon customer review
Snooply 57December 14, 2013
Run, do not walk, from Benjamin steakhouse. Unpleasant dining experience from start to finish.
Denise AlvarengaAugust 27, 2015
Steak with potatoes !
Kelli MMay 2, 2013
Their Manhattan is truely sublime.
Houlihan LawrenceJuly 19, 2013
The best rib eye in Westchester!

1 2

381 Photos

Benjamin Steakhouse

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Benjamin Steakhouse

Appears on 319 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.