Bartolotta's Pizzeria Piccola
Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$
Wauwatosa
Ranked #2 for pizzerias in Wauwatosa
"Bread Knots and Flourless Chocolate Cake are to die for!"(6 Tips)
"Excellent pizza with delicious specials; super staff."(19 Tips)
"Fave Pizza: Spicy Pepperoni They offer Gluten-free options too!"(2 Tips)
"Get a flourless chocolate cake for dessert, too!"(2 Tips)
28 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- bread knots
- pizza
- good service
- bruschetta
- flourless chocolate cake
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Brent GatewoodMay 21, 2018I enjoyed the pizza here. Nice crust, good tomato sauce, and very good sausage. Kind of a fun spot for a quick pizza, enjoy!
Kurt GrosAugust 6, 2014Came here without knowing anything about it and was pleasantly surprised! The bread knots were excellent, bruschetta very good, and the oven-fired margarita pizza outstanding!- Jeni BartoszewiczApril 24, 2012Must eats: Bread knots= buttery-garlicky-goodness! Pasta: Penne a la Bolognese (Meat ragu, tomato sauce, parmesan) DELICIOUS! Fave Pizza: Spicy Pepperoni They offer Gluten-free options too!
My usual-Veggie pizza w/spicy pepperoni-it is SPICY! The bolognese pasta is good too. Be on time if u pick up or your crust will be soggy. Call for the 2 daily pizzas that won't on the menu. Enjoy!
Bread knots are a dietary staple for me...they should be for you as well! The classic Margherita Pizza is always fantastic but even more so when you add the chicken sausage and gorgonzola!
Allysha HeenanJuly 13, 2013So good! Get the apple and Gorgonzola pizza! Wine of summer is Roscato and shouldn't be missed. Oh and yes, bread knot-try those too.
Kalai TaiHookJanuary 19, 2013Excellent gluten-free pasta and bread knots. Looking forward to trying the GF pizza.- Max TwietmeyerJune 8, 2012I love the Chicken Panino with added bell peppers, yum! The caesar salad is also incredible.
- VISIT MilwaukeeJune 20, 2011Try their Gluten-free pizzas and pastas! "Anti-Gluteneers" rejoice! Get a flourless chocolate cake for dessert, too!
Best bruschetta in the city - completely fresh and garlicky! Delish!
Be careful of the soda machine upstairs. Ice comes out quick.
The veggie pizza is delish, & with the whole wheat crust it's even healthy!- Blake SamicOctober 16, 2009they have an awesome lunch deal - 1/2 personal pizza and soup or salad for $5.50
Michael ChangJune 28, 2012Don't order anything other than pizza. They'll forget to fire the rest of the order.
78 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
(414) 443-0800
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer, Wine
See More
You might also like
- 8.5
"Must get the fried eggplant strips! Very light on the batter, and best with the Parmesan dipping sauce! I had the rigatoni with sausage and peas- surprising lemon flavor to it. Refreshing."
Hailey - 7.8
"Great service, friendly people and AWESOME FOOD! !"
Rob Marki - 6.9
"like the option of the salad bar instead of pizza"
pattie c
Places people like to go after Bartolotta's Pizzeria Piccola
- 8.9
"Gluten and dairy free frozen yogurt!! Love the cherry and orange splash flavored!!"
Stefani - 8.6
"I recommend this charming restaurant! Good food, nice staff and outdoor eating, too!"
Cherri Pierangeli Kasdorf - 8.7
"Loved the Papaya flavor! Stopped in here after a movie at the Times Cinema, great place to hit in the Summer!"
Stefani
Appears on 27 lists
Created by Rebecca Combs
6 items • 10 followers
Must Visit Local Milwaukee Establishments
Created by David
20 items • 6 followers
Created by MyCommunityNOW
76 items • 59 followers