Important Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.Bait & Hook Seafood Shack
(Now Closed)Seafood Restaurant$$$$
Gramercy Park, New York
54 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Sunny HuiAugust 6, 2013Lunch special chipotle chicken sandwich is yummy for $10! Not a big fan of their lobster roll.. Their calamari is delicious with their mayo sauce!
Dominique BOctober 20, 2013Nice place good ambiance. Hawaiian love is the best drink on the menu. I had the scallops n lobster risotto. Scallops were amazin lobster risotto wasn't tasty. Rice was under cooked
David HuDecember 31, 2014Awesome deal to be had if you come on a taco Tuesday during happy hour (5-7p) -- beers are $5, and oysters and fish tacos are $1 each!
Olessya KJune 9, 2013Great crab cakes appetizer. Not a fan of lobster risotto, but absolutely fantastic fish tacos. And the staff is just wonderful. Recommend!
💎TNovember 5, 2014$1 oysters for happy hour. $1 fish tacos on Tuesdays. Their lobster mac is a must try!
Michael BayleOctober 13, 201325 cent wings; $1 oysters ; $10 pitchers! It's like they are paying you to watch football. Great friendly staff and much more civilized than Finnerty's
Paula MFJune 9, 2015Good seafood, mediocre cocktails. Get a beer instead. Happy hour super worth it just for the $1 oyster special (like everyone's already said)- Elle F.October 13, 2016$5 Mussels on Monday, $1 Oysters on Thursday. Daily Happy Hour Specials 3-7PM, Includes $1 Oysters and $3 Fish Tacos.
Brian BrewerJuly 15, 2013The grilled salmon and ginger crusted tilapia are delish! The salmon tartar was a sizeable and tasty starter, too.
Malcolm RingOctober 27, 2015$1 Oysters 3-7PM M-F, All Day Th, $1 Tacos Tues, 1/2 Price Wine Bottles Wed. B&H generally well priced.
Friendly staff, full bar and if you check-in on four square, you get a nice discount. Highly recommend!
Juliana AmorimSeptember 27, 20141$ oysters every day on HH. Salmon and aspargus are great, fish and chips too, go for it. ;)
Shi Tsyr ChenAugust 9, 2014Tuesdays tacos are 1$ and there's live music. Great food - especially the fries and lobster Mac n cheese.
Jason CianoNovember 24, 2015Fish tacos pretty good. Tuesday's $3.00 for 3!!! All day and night. Crab cake a little bland but great mixed greens.
Ashley VelazquezSeptember 3, 2020I’ve been dying to try Bait & Hook, and I have to say that I’m definitely disappointed. Expect warm, flat soda in a glass with ice, and mediocre food and portions.
Happy hour has $4 beer and wine specials and $1 oysters. Yummy.
Jenn PeddeOctober 4, 2014If you sit outside, you'll hear a siren of some sort every 3 minutes - no exaggeration.
Brittany ThompsonJune 24, 2013The lobster roll is amazing! Along with the oysters - so great. Can't wait to go back!
Bait & Hook Seafood ShackDecember 15, 2012Did you enjoy your meal at Bait & Hook? Help us spread the word and post your review & Like us on Foursquare today! Thanks for your support!
Carla MoscosoJune 2, 2013HH mango margarita & $1 blue point oysters are on the money. They just need to boost the A/C.
Best cucumber margaritas courtesy of the best bartender Jimi!
Harry JacobsSeptember 18, 2016Taco Tuesday special was wack. Can only get 1 order of tacos per drink and they're pitifully tiny.
Judy KennedyNovember 26, 2014Restaurant front looks cute and inviting but that's as far as it went; Bloody Mary was ok, 1$ fish tacos where what you'd expect of 1$ tacos. The mussels were hard and had no taste, service was poor.
If you thought you loved lobster rolls, try the SCALLOP rolls. Ahhhmazing!
John GSeptember 17, 2012Raw oysters? Yes, shrimp cocktail? Hell yes. Seared scallops and lentil salad? Off the hook!
Foxytk23April 1, 2013Thank u four square for getting me 50% off my check. Fried clams n fish n chips. Yum
- Lears FoolFebruary 12, 2016Taco tuesday is okay, but not all tacos are available. Just the boring ones.
41 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
231 2nd Ave at E. 14th St, New York, NY
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- Noon–Midnight
(212) 260-8015
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.4
"The lobster rolls were absolutely delicious. Grab a pack of salt and vinegar chips while you're at it."
George Joseph - 8.4
"Fantastic cocktails (particularly the coconut and the squash) and life-changing small plates. Best when someone else is paying."
Kat - 9.0
"$1 raw oysters during happy hour were amazing! They were shucked so well! I would pay more than $1 for them any day!"
Will Skiles
Places people like to go after Bait & Hook Seafood Shack
Appears on 121 lists
Created by Kino
153 items • 37 followers
Created by Talia Fisher
180 items • 33 followersCreated by Talia Fisher
37 items • 11 followers