Bagel Boss Hicksville
Bagel Shop and Deli$$$$
Hicksville
"white salad an light veggie tuna with a sunflower seed flagel"(4 Tips)
"Best whole wheat everything bagels and tasty soups year-round."(6 Tips)
"The best baked salmon salad on Long Island"(3 Tips)
"Free WiFi..Big Room in back to sit n work..open 24hrs...incredible!"(4 Tips)
54 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- bagels
- flagels
- good for a late night
- lox
- great value
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Rich KruseMarch 20, 2013Say hi To GM Scott Perskin..great guy..great bagels n coffee. Free WiFi..Big Room in back to sit n work..open 24hrs...incredible!
Peter FeldmanDecember 13, 2013I grew up eating these bagels and now that I've move out of long island I still come back every other week to pick up a couple of dozen yo throw in the freezer.
Open 24 hours which is great. The staff isn't too friendly which was a little frustrating to deal with. Great selection, though.
If you don't like the side salads and want a tuna bagel,etc, order the tuna on the side (1/4 pound) and you'll save some money. And Muffin tops taste fresher than the actual whole muffins!!
Janine BSeptember 15, 2024The scallion cream cheese on my bagel had basically three scallion bits in it. You have to laugh
Now charging 4% more if you pay by credit card - that shows they truly value my business!
BagelGram JaffeDecember 1, 2014when you see 'Flagel' on the menu, make sure you pronounce it correctly: "FLAY-gul"
Inching closer and closer to me doesn't make the line move faster, it just makes me wanna punch you old woman.
Best Bagels in the World! Try the Mushroom...Onion...Egg Salad and the Tuna with Green Apples...Raisins...and Cranberries...Yum! : )
Explore Long IslandFebruary 27, 2013We featured Bagel Boss and other stores in our guide for "Great food shops on Long Island!" Read more
Matt SzenicsJanuary 14, 2012Great baked salmon salad on a bagel. Also one of the few 24hour spots around.- Order your jelly on the side they never put enough on themselves. I always do this except for the other day and there was barely any jelly on my bagel.
- Spinach & egg white salad an light veggie tuna with a sunflower seed flagel, amazing!
- Try the spinach & egg white salad mixed w/ veggie tuna so tasty! I get mine w/ a sunflower seed flagel.
Egg everything bagel + everything cream cheese. Most fun bagel ever.
Don’t go when the teens are working alone. Even if there is one customer ahead the others run away and leave you waiting
Andrew JonesSeptember 25, 2011This should be your last option when choosing a place to get bagels. Try bagel master instead.
- Keep an eye out for bugs around the pastries before buying
Sunflower flagel w/ cream cheese + martinelli's apple juice=heaven on earth- Mmm excellent Everything Bagels! Why can't they make these in LA?!?!
76 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Bagel Boss Hicksville
432 S Oyster Bay Rd (Woodbury Rd.)
Hicksville, NY 11801
United States
Hicksville, NY 11801
United States
Family owned, dairy kosher, and home of the best bagels Long Island has to offer. Oh, and we're open 24/7!
Open (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 24 Hours
(516) 681-1856
Features
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch
See More
