Attaboy
Speakeasy and Cocktail Bar$$$$
Lower East Side, New York
Has a stamp of approval from Eater and Time Out New York
"wrong with the Penicillin"(12 Tips)
"original Milk and Honey"(5 Tips)
"The best bespoke cocktails in NYC now?"(5 Tips)
"Best new bar in town, in the old Milk & Honey space."(4 Tips)
234 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- cocktails
- good for dates
- trendy
- penicillin
- boozy drinks
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- Best new bar in town, in the old Milk & Honey space. There's a new longer bar, no reservation policy and they now serve wine & beer as well as classic cocktails. Great vibe & awesome service!Upvoted Jan 2
Find the door marked AB and ring the bell to get buzzed in. Tell them your preferred liquor & flavor profiles. Interesting combos come up but be patient as they may take a while. Always worth the wait
Upvoted Nov 23, 2024
Probably one of my favorite cocktails bar i've ever been in the NYC. You get asked what spirit you like and the cocktail experts make you something unique every time. Knock twice, leave your name.
Ring the bell on the unmarked 124AB door to put your name down. There is no menu - you tell them what flavour profiles you like. Great bartenders and drinks. Very cool speakeasy vibes.
Victoria NatenzonMay 3, 2014Best speakeasy in this city. Tell the mixologist what you're feeling and he'll create the best concoction of your life. Tiny place so go on a Sunday night to get in without a wait.
Lauren Evelyn AnneJuly 31, 2015Amazing cocktails with bartenders that know their stuff. Think outside the box here for your perfect drink since there's no formal menu. Ask for a white negroni- the best I've ever had.- The best bespoke cocktails in NYC now? Sam Ross, the owner, created the Penicillin. Even if you don't like scotch, order it. Then get the "Ralphacillin", a riff with maple dark rum.
Ranu RajkarnikarJuly 15, 2015Delicious bespoke drinks and a cool hidden exterior. Loved the beekeeper drink I had with bourbon and honey. An intimate space that's great for a date or catching up with an old friend.
Lauren MacDecember 18, 2015👌🏼 Put your name early, hang out at Fig 19. when you return, sit back & let the bartenders work their magic. There's a dedication to the craft here & appreciation for detail, esp. if you sit barside
Alex TsuMay 9, 2018A truly spectacular speakeasy offering custom drinks based on your preferences; tell the bartender what flavors you like and watch him make the cocktail you've been dreaming of.
s vJune 7, 2017(Thrillist tip) No menu, so get comfortable w/ the pro bar staff and bare your soul..modern classics, like the Penicillin, with whiskey, honey-ginger syrup, lemon, and Islay Scotch.
My favorite cocktail bar in New York. Knock on the door and put your name in. They'll call you when your table is ready. Drinks are amazing just tell them what you feel like and go from there.
Harrison JohnsonOctober 14, 2017The classic. Get there early or expect to wait at a nearby bar (try RPM). This place will make you feel special. No menu, just say what you're feeling. Drinks are 💪 but some of the best in the world
Billy JacobsonOctober 17, 2015Cocktails are amazing. Atmosphere is super chill and not crowded. The list moves pretty fast and you can explore other places around there while you wait
AntonyJanuary 27, 2024Superlatively good. I've been to many cocktail bars but the expertise here is one of the best I've ever experienced. Yet still very down to earth, friendly and accessible. The hype is justified.
dsinskyMay 11, 2014Apparently the owner (who bartends regularly) is the inventor of the penicillin and, unsurprisingly, his version is the best in the city. The imperial buck is also spectacular.
Marie RicherSeptember 16, 2016The cocktails here are great and made custom according to your preferences. They're pricey but very strong and worth it! Also the bartenders are really friendly.
Dan BartonMay 29, 2017Took over Little Branch for my favorite speakeasy in the city. One of the owners, Michael, was an amazing bartender and we had a perfect time. About :45 minute wait on a Sunday, the place is popular.
Scott PfluglerApril 15, 2017Longer wait, but the drinks are amazing. No menu, bartender just asks what spirits and flavors you like and delivers a great drink. The wait is worth it so the bar isn't packed all the time.- Wendy QiuJanuary 26, 2015Flavor Profile - asked for gin, cucumber and fruit puree. Got the best cocktail - with strawberries, not overbearing, and refreshing. Not sure it was worth the $16 and 1 hr wait ....
Marianne NJune 6, 2018No menus, the bar tender works out what you like and creates something for you. She was spot on. Look for the door marked “AB”.
Shawn PoppSeptember 26, 2024Really small and really dark. Love it! Cool format. No menu, $22 drinks. Music was a bit loud, hard to have a conversation but overall it was a great time. Really looking forward to the next time
StephanySeptember 23, 2014Had a few cocktails that changed my life. Outstanding Old Fashioned if you want to stick to a classic .
Amy ChenJuly 16, 2015Definitely bring someone here for a date. The waiter takes care of you and makes sure you are happy. The drinks are phenomenal, and there's a consistent low murmur. Awesome vibes.
Joanne CroninOctober 30, 2014I was feeling in the mood for tequila, so I first revived a bracing stirred drink, Tres Hands, with tequila, mezcal & vermouth. This was followed by a sweeter, lighter Ju Ju. Both top notch
Lauren HeppsOctober 10, 2014Seriously skip all the stupid mustaches and suspenders at the other speakeasys and check this place out. Great staff. Great cocktails. Great patrons. Love it!
Great cocktails, do bartenders choice. Wait to get in is long, so put your name down and then go for a pre-snack or drink somewhere else in the neighborhood while you wait. Worth the wait.
Mayank MahajanJuly 30, 2018Excellent cocktails, all made without a menu. Venture out your comfort zone and be surprised with what you get!
steven barbarichJune 3, 2022Fantastic drinks with personal service. Drinks are made based on your mood/preference. The bartender was lovely. Perfect place to connect with an old friend over great drinks.
Edwina McGregorJuly 30, 2017Without a doubt one of the best cocktail bars I've ever been to. No menu. Just tell the bartender what flavours you feel like and you'll get your own unique cocktail.
Just say what you're in the mood for and they will find the right cocktail for you. There is no menu. There is no vodka.
Alyssa B.December 11, 2022Menu-less, what’s your vibe place. Loved the Hotel Nacionale! The wait for 5 on a Monday night at 8pm was an hour… way better than I expected
Beka CMay 5, 2015Good mixology spot for a date or catching up with a friend or two. Must get seated so it doesn't get crowded or too loud but the actual crowd is all over the place. Nice bartenders.
Jason BrewJuly 8, 2016Say hi to the camera above the gray door that says "AB" on it to gain entry. There's no drink menu so just talk to the bartender about what you like and they'll invent you a drink!
Zach RSeptember 22, 2015Amazing place to grab unique cocktails. Smile for the camera and someone will come greet you at the door. Expect a wait, but they call when your seats are ready.
Time Out New YorkOctober 5, 2018From the up-tempo retro tunes to the brightly lit, lived-in digs (whitewashed brick, tarnished a sign hanging on the wall), Attaboy proves a breezy evolution of the form. Read more
Colleen SheaApril 16, 2017If U ever get in the expensive drinks will be worth it. Speakeasy atmosphere. No cocktail list, tell the bartender what u like & he'll make u something!They call u when seats open,could take a while.- Michael Fox-RabinovitzFebruary 26, 2017Fantastic atmosphere, low key, great drink creations and friendly and knowledgeable staff. Get there early, place is small, wait will be long later
ChrisDecember 27, 2019You’ll need to look carefully to find this spot. Plan on a wait to get into this small, dark cocktail bar. Great drinks!
Kate FurmanOctober 18, 2016Look for 134 AB Eldridge Street, a nondescript grey door, and ring the bell. This is a no menu speakeasy, tell the bartender what liquor and flavors you prefer in your drinks.
The bartender asks you what you like and comes back with an amazing concoction. It's intimate, interesting and well worth it.
- Christopher GutierrezFebruary 4, 2015This is *the* best cocktail bar I've ever been to. Give the a rough idea of what you want or the mood you are in and they will make you an amazing drink.
Joe FontanaFebruary 3, 2015Tell them the mood your in. Don't ask questions. Sip some amazement!! I've been welcome here for years and there's nothing better than a cocktail prepared by guys who love making cocktails- Can't go wrong with the Penicillin, or just ask for what your heart desires. Best to go in small groups, highest chances of getting in.
Ross WSJanuary 10, 2018There is no menu but you can trust that your bartender will ask the right questions to bring you something utterly unexpected but right on. Still a must-visit in a city overrun with new openings.
Jeff SolomonOctober 22, 2017There is no menu. Instead, the host asks what you’re interested in drinking and then they come up with something that fits your tastes on the spot. Highly recommend
KathrineDecember 28, 2019Amazing cocktails, all dealer’s choice. Expect to wait and hour or two for a table, but plan ahead for it—totally worth it!
GREAT cocktails in old milk & honey space. way more chill now, some of the bartenders are Aussies!! Has weird opening hours like 6:45 or something like that.
446 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 5:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 5:00 PM–3:00 AM
(855) 877-9900
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Drinks
Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.7
"Fun little hidden bar that gets a bit crowded on weekends. The gin cocktail is delicious and refreshing, not a lot of seating but the vibe is loud and fun!"
Colleen Shea - 8.9
"A nice, relaxing lounge to grab a drink. Lines can be long on weekends but it's worth it, especially if you love a classic jazzy atmosphere."
New York Habitat - 8.9
"Favorite stop when visiting NYC, great drink selections and atmosphere."
Eva Villarreal
Places people like to go after Attaboy
- 8.7
"Try Sesame pancake w Szechuan style beef sauce, chive and pork dumplings - they both have strong yummy flavours!"
Irina - 8.7
"Salads, grilled cheese, the slushy cocktail, ango shots. One of the best bars in town"
Doctore Aguacate - 8.1
"Great cocktails and a low key vibe. Was there on a random Monday and they had a live jazz band and serious dancing. Legit"
Bob Gearing
Appears on 4,153 lists
Speakeasy bars and secret restaurants in NYC
Created by Meng He
67 items • 934 followers
Created by naveen
22 items • 821 followers
50 Top Cocktail Bars in the U.S.
Created by Foursquare Swarm
50 items • 759 followers
