Shelter Island

Shelter Island

Creator Avatar
Created by Andrew Norton • Updated On: May 5, 2023
Michelangelo's is one of Shelter Island.

1. Michelangelo's

8.1
53345 Route 25, Southold, NY
Italian Restaurant · 13 tips and reviews
Farm Country Kitchen is one of Shelter Island.

2. Farm Country Kitchen

8.6
513 W Main St (at W Main Street), Riverhead, NY
Sandwich Spot · 110 tips and reviews
Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe is one of Shelter Island.

3. Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe

7.4
Smith Street (Midway Road), Shelter Island, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews
Islander is one of Shelter Island.

4. Islander

7.8
63 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
Breakfast Spot · 9 tips and reviews
Red Maple is one of Shelter Island.

5. Red Maple

7.7
23 Grand Ave, Shelter Island, NY
American Restaurant · 1 tip
Marie Eiffel Market is one of Shelter Island.

6. Marie Eiffel Market

8.3
184 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY
Restaurant · 11 tips and reviews
Villa Italian Specialties is one of Shelter Island.

7. Villa Italian Specialties

8.6
7 Railroad Ave, East Hampton, NY
Italian Restaurant · 22 tips and reviews
Harbor Market & Kitchen is one of Shelter Island.

8. Harbor Market & Kitchen

8.8
184 Division St (Henry St.), Sag Harbor, NY
Restaurant · 10 tips and reviews
Hampton Chutney Co. is one of Shelter Island.

9. Hampton Chutney Co.

9.1
6 Main St, Amagansett, NY
Indian Restaurant · 26 tips and reviews
Tate's Bake Shop is one of Shelter Island.

10. Tate's Bake Shop

9.1
43 N Sea Rd (Windmill La.), Southampton, NY
Bakery · 62 tips and reviews