Alonzo's Oyster Bar
American Restaurant, Seafood Restaurant, and Pub$$$$
Key West
"Buffalo shrimp & conch fritters are fantastic."(8 Tips)
"The coconut grouper is amazing.. 10-30-10"(4 Tips)
"Conch Fritters, Steamed Clams, Calamari, It's All Good!!!!"(5 Tips)
"Try the oyster sampler if you can't decide, they are all delicious!"(24 Tips)
103 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- happy hour
- coconut grouper
- baked key
- conch fritters
- good for groups
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Elena Jacobs LopezJuly 28, 2016Savannah the bartender won't do you wrong! Their specialty drinks r 🌟 all great! Mumm by the glass is $5! Alonzo's Oyster appetizer is great! Smoked fish dip, conch fritters, mozz salad very tasty.Upvoted 2 weeks ago
Keya LilBengalMarch 22, 2013I hear the oysters are good, but I tried the conch fritters (all breading). If you want good conch, go to CONCH REPUBLIC SEAFOOD COMPANY on Greene St. They have cracked conch and chowder to die for!
Yaron KergetSeptember 18, 2016Lobster roll is just a giant tasty monster, so huge you can easily order it for 2 hungry people. And get the Kumamoto oysters they are good ones, taste like European, other kind of oysters is just bad
Curt ReesApril 9, 2013Their happy hour is fantastic. Drinks and apps are half price. The sampler app plate was delicious and you get a lot of food to share. Great scenery outside. Fun environment inside.
LolaJanuary 11, 2015Tuna tartar, lobster and even stone crabs were just delicious! Looking forward to come back. Unfortunately they have no wi-fi. At least we enjoyed the atmosphere even more :)
Stettler GageApril 17, 2016I come here for happy hour whenever I'm in Florida. Very good shrimp. I've come here with parties of eleven or parties of 8 people and the service has always been exceptional.
Suzie WiersumMay 11, 2013So delicious. We got here for the tail end of happy hour. Get here early for 1/2 price drinks & apps. Get buffalo shrimp & key lime pie!!
Nika VaskaJanuary 6, 2020Good selection of oysters. Good location of the restaurant. Cooking was veeeery slow though. The food was ok. Nice and friendly Russian waiter. Sangria had more ice the sangria itself.
Tracy Shirk KelleyJanuary 24, 2013The Baked Key Lime Oysters were great, as well as the Buffalo Shrimp! Best time to go is happy hour 4p-6p, huge selection of half price apps and drinks!
Chingona SApril 19, 2014The scallops from the salad Mango Scallops are very bitter, we all ordered it and everyone says so. The dressing of the salad is enough either. 😔
evaDecember 1, 2018Fabulous service. Awesome happy hour. 1/2 off all wines. Spinach cheese oysters to die for!
Jennifer RussoJune 8, 2015The oyster combo plate is great - you can try key lime, buffalo and spinach baked oysters. :-)
Phil CatelinetJuly 23, 2013The half-price appetizers and drinks from 4-6:30 is a great way to get a snack before the sunset party at Mallory Square.
Great happy hour deal. Daily from 4 to 630 @ the bar. Half off all drinks and apps. Fresh seafood and excellent service!
Debra ParmaAugust 26, 2014The crispy lobster sandwich was amazing. I've never had anything like it before. 😍😍👌👌🙌🙌
Freesoul YMay 18, 2015Favorite restaurant in keywest. Try oyster, clam and shrimp. Entrees are good too.
Kathy DelgadoSeptember 22, 2013From 4 to 6:30 its happy hour. All drinks & appetizers are 1/2 off the fried shrimp & buffalo oysters are delish!- NoelleJune 25, 2014Try the oyster sampler if you can't decide, they are all delicious! Conch fritters are great too.
- kimberly nJanuary 23, 2020$2 blue point oysters for happy hour. $6 1000 stories bourbon barrel wine is worth it
Janessa SimmonsFebruary 8, 2022The happy hour is the best!!! I highly recommend the conch fritters…..
Jan FreemanMay 6, 2015Delicious uniquely prepared salads. Tarpon feedings just feet away from outdoor seating.
Delta BoundJuly 16, 2012This is snapper topped with onion strings on top of smashed potato with a bearnaise sauce.
Blair HerndonJanuary 23, 2013Sarah is a great server :) we made it here in time for the 4 pm happy hour and fish feeding... Definitely worth it
Tiffany RJuly 4, 2011Happy hour is one of the best in terms of apps and drinks for 1/2 price. Go at 4pm to get a seat on the water!
Morgan DesperMay 3, 2013Great food. Definitely come here for happy hour!! Great deals and FANTASTIC FOOD
ShariMay 29, 2012Food was wonderful!! Huge improvement. Didn't eat here for a long time after a bad meal but huge improvement! Kudos to the new management!
Ivetta AbramyanDecember 21, 2011Must try: key lime oysters & buffalo shrimp! Also, the key lime martini and bloody mary are phenomenal!
Kate FurmanFebruary 8, 2016A touristy seafood restaurant at the waterfront. The greek salad with shrimp was good except for the shrimp was overcooked.
Meshi DavisMarch 28, 2012The view, people watching, and great staff service! I recommend sitting outside.
Thomas JohnsonJune 15, 2014Very disappointing especially with the buffalo shrimp, and the majority of the Happy Hour menu Oyster were a 😕
329 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Beginning May 4, 2020: Alonzo’s Oyster Bar will be open for on-premises consumption of food and beverage while practicing appropriate social distancing measures and limit indoor occupancy to no more than 25%. Outdoor seating will be available with appropriate social distancing. In addition, only ...
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
(305) 600-3405
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
No
Parking
Street, Private Lot
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.2
"The lobster bisque is amazing!!"
Courtney Harden - 8.4
"Caroline's never disappoints. Great food and great people. One of my favorites is the salad deluxe!"
Rebecca Duncan - 7.1
"Key West blackened fish sandwich & tacos are awesome. Large filet of perfectly grilled fish and light tasty Cajun spices."
Bill Schillhammer
Places people like to go after Alonzo's Oyster Bar
- 9.0
"Great place for family's. Street performances...lots of shopping...great sunsets"
Sarah Warfield - 8.6
"Atmosphere, entertainment, souvenirs, and of course the infamous Sloppy Joes. Don't miss it!"
Jill Brailey - 8.5
"Fish tacos are phenom. Dog friendly with some great characters. I feel like the local boozers really love this place. (4 of 4 petals via Fondu)"
Mike Lewis
Appears on 62 lists
Guide to Key West's best spots
Created by Jeremy Fisher
8 items • 4 followersCreated by Candice Coolahan
30 items • 3 followers
Created by Kathy Watkins
12 items • 8 followers
