Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants
Pio Pio is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

1. Pio Pio

8.0
210 E 34th St (btwn 2nd & 3rd Ave.), New York, NY
Peruvian Roast Chicken Joint · Murray Hill · 103 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: The food is always very fresh. Keep in mind they only accept cash and Amex for payment. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/785114/Pio-Pio-Restaurant

Mercadito is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

2. Mercadito

179 Avenue B (btwn E 11th & E 12th St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Alphabet City · 99 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: They were very accommodating as our party grew at the last minute and they found a way to squeeze us in to an already packed dining room. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/6791/Mercadito-Cantina

The Perfect Pint is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

3. The Perfect Pint

6.4
123 W 45th St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Irish Pub · Theater District · 81 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: The Hogwarts of beer. The food is excellent bar fare and the staff is extremely attentive... Magical really. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/5256/Perfect-Pint

Tony's Di Napoli is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

4. Tony's Di Napoli

8.7
147 W 43rd St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Theater District · 235 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: The portions are huge so this is a great place for fat people and group dining alike. Unfortunately for me I fall into the first category. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/5331/Tonys-DiNapoli

Macao Trading Company is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

5. Macao Trading Company

8.9
311 Church St (btwn Lispenard & Walker St), New York, NY
Asian Restaurant · Tribeca · 229 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: Amazing service coupled with great food make Macao Trading a great place for a special group dinner. Be warned, the portions are small. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/218637/Macao-Trading-Co

Pampano is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

6. Pampano

7.6
209 E 49th St (btwn 3rd Ave & 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 86 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: The Good: The food is amazing, even the salad was one of the best I've ever had. The Bad: Really, really expensive. The Verdict: Worth every penny. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/652878/Pampano

Gyu-Kaku Japanese BBQ is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

7. Gyu-Kaku Japanese BBQ

8.2
805 3rd Ave (btwn E 49th & E 50th St), New York, NY
Japanese Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 159 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: Japanese take on Korean BBQ - the meat is high quality, everything is fresh. There's a good atmosphere & the booths are cozy and have a private feel. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/6629/Gyu-Kaku

Jones Wood Foundry is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

8. Jones Wood Foundry

8.6
401 E 76th St (btwn York & 1st Ave.), New York, NY
English Restaurant · Upper East Side · 156 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: It's a neat spot if you're into wine bars. The bartenders aren't very attentive, nor friendly, but it's a great physical space. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/7000/Jones-Wood-Foundry

Caffe Buon Gusto - Manhattan is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

9. Caffe Buon Gusto - Manhattan

8.4
236 E 77th St, New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper East Side · 39 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: A very intimate romantic restaurant. It's the perfect place to eat on a nice spring evening, make sure to sit out in the backyard. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/5077/Caffe-Buon-Gusto

Dos Caminos is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

10. Dos Caminos

7.0
373 Park Ave S (at E 27th St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Rose Hill · 183 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: Get the Guacamole. Can be loud and a little pricey, but a fun night out with friends if you don't mind spending a little more than normal. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/5335/Dos-Caminos-Park

Boat Basin Cafe is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

11. Boat Basin Cafe

W 79th St (at Riverside Park), New York, NY
Café · Upper West Side · 210 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: Nice outdoor bar, good happy hour for after work. Sit next to the water and see beautiful views of northern nj. Food is average at best. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/6531/Boat-Basin-Cafe

Blue Smoke is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

12. Blue Smoke

116 E 27th St (btwn Park Ave S & Lexington Ave), New York, NY
BBQ Joint · Rose Hill · 416 tips and reviews
Le Souk Restaurant & Lounge is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

13. Le Souk Restaurant & Lounge

6.2
510 Laguardia Pl (btwn Bleecker St & W Houston St), New York, NY
Hookah Bar · Greenwich Village · 131 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: Sexy and fun. While quite expensive Le Souk is worth a visit. The food is quite good, but you're paying for the ambiance. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/1000000/Le-Souk-Harem

Bar Luna is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

14. Bar Luna

511 Amsterdam Ave (86th St), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Upper West Side · 8 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: I proposed to Jeanette here. Bar Luna is a very intimate restaurant that is perfect for a special romantic date. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/6639/Bar-Luna

Sofrito is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

15. Sofrito

400 E 57th St (at 1st Ave), New York, NY
Latin American Restaurant · Sutton Place · 126 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: If you have the patience to wait around for a drink and table you'll be happy you did. The festive ambiance makes the high price tag worth it. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/265928/Sofrito

Calle Ocho is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

16. Calle Ocho

2756 Broadway (at 106th St), New York, NY
Cuban Restaurant · Upper West Side · 292 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: Probably my favorite restaurant in the city. Great food, creative drinks, and an amazing dining room make this a place must visit. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/4823/Calle-Ocho

Maya is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

17. Maya

8.3
1191 1st Ave (btwn E 64th St & E 65th St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Upper East Side · 148 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: Been there several times, very good Mexican food. Maya has great ambiance for a romantic dinner. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/4533/Maya

Luscious Thai is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

18. Luscious Thai

1099 1st Ave (at 60th St), New York, NY
Thai Restaurant · Upper East Side · 21 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: Very good thai in UES. As always with thai food my favorite is chicken pad thai. Thankfully they don't go overboard on the thai sauce. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/6673/Luscious-Thai

John & Tony's is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

19. John & Tony's

6.8
1097 1st Ave (at 60th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Upper East Side · 18 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: One of the best slices on the upper east side! http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/580138/John-and-Tonys-Trattoria-Caffe

TAO Uptown is one of Mecritic Founder's Favorite Resturants.

20. TAO Uptown

8.7
42 E 58th St (btwn Madison & Park Ave), New York, NY
Asian Restaurant · Midtown East · 390 tips and reviews

MeCritic.comMeCritic.com: The big golden statue and the lively atmosphere make this a fun place to visit. Haven't been recently but it's time to go back. http://www.mecritic.com/places/place/6113/Tao