The Top Rated Pie Shops in Chicago

9.3

2051 N California Ave (at N Point St), Chicago, IL

Pie Shop · Logan Square · 120 tips and reviews

Erik Rowley: Sunday afternoons are the perfect time to relax and treat yourself to some pie, the chocolate pecan is incredible.

First Slice Pie Café is one of The Top Rated Pie Shops in Chicago.

2. First Slice Pie Café

8.8

5357 N Ashland Ave (at W Balmoral Ave), Chicago, IL

Pie Shop · Andersonville · 21 tips and reviews

Stephen: I got the apple pie - OMG. Massive and delicious. The star of the show was definitely the crust. So good.

Hoosier Mama Pie Company is one of The Top Rated Pie Shops in Chicago.

3. Hoosier Mama Pie Company

8.9

1618 W Chicago Ave (at N Ashland Ave), Chicago, IL

Pie Shop · East Ukrainian Village · 68 tips and reviews

Jonathan Ferrera: The chocolate chess pie is quite great. They have a great selection of pies depending on the season. The blueberry pie is excellent as well.

First Slice Pie Cafe is one of The Top Rated Pie Shops in Chicago.

4. First Slice Pie Cafe

8.6

4664 N Manor Ave, Chicago, IL

Pie Shop · Ravenswood Manor · 11 tips and reviews

Tiffany Wong: i have fond memories of the peanut butter pie