Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Ithaca's Best Pizzerias
Ciao! is one of Ithaca's Best Pizzerias.

1. Ciao!

8.0
2 Hickory Hollow Ln (at N. Triphammer Rd.), Ithaca, NY
Italian Restaurant · 30 tips and reviews

14850 Dining14850 Dining: These 11-inch brick-oven pizzas start at just $9, with creative combinations of toppings. Share an appetizer and a pizza for an affordable meal! Vegan cheese and gluten-free crusts are available.

Napoli Pizza is one of Ithaca's Best Pizzerias.

2. Napoli Pizza

7.1
401 E State St (at Green St), Ithaca, NY
Pizzeria · 4 tips and reviews

14850 Dining14850 Dining: Napoli's roots go back decades in downtown Ithaca, and they know how to make their pizza, our favorite among the area's traditional, round pizzas. Napoli also has by far the best wings in town.

The Nines is one of Ithaca's Best Pizzerias.

3. The Nines

311 College Ave, Ithaca, NY
Pizzeria · 32 tips and reviews

14850 Dining14850 Dining: The square deep-dish pizza is the Nines's forte, with a broad array of toppings and a thick crust. The four square slices easily feed two or three people, four if you add appetizers.

Ithaca Beer Co. Taproom is one of Ithaca's Best Pizzerias.

4. Ithaca Beer Co. Taproom

8.8
122 Ithaca Beer Dr, Ithaca, NY
Brewery · 77 tips and reviews

14850 Dining14850 Dining: Excellent ten-inch wood-fired pizzas, featuring dough made with organic flour from New York State's Champlain Valley Milling. Classic combos and frequent special toppings.

Papa John's Pizza is one of Ithaca's Best Pizzerias.

5. Papa John's Pizza

6.5
435 Franklin St (3rd St), Ithaca, NY
Pizzeria · 2 tips and reviews

14850 Dining14850 Dining: One of the best traditional, round pizzas in town, thanks to fresh ingredients and their surprisingly affordable prices. We love the garlic dipping sauce and hot peppers that come with each pizza.