Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill Restaurant

American Restaurant and Steakhouse$$$$

Mendham

Save

7.8^/10

ratings

"Shrimp scampie was amazing!"(2 Tips)
"The specialty cider martinis are especially delicious!!"(2 Tips)
"penne vodka and garlic oil spaghetti"(2 Tips)
"... while you're at the bar you ask to see where they pumped the hooch..."(3 Tips)

7 Tips and reviews

Filter:

Sort:

AJNFebruary 16, 2013
Shrimp scampie was amazing! Had it as an appetizer. Delicious. I would say Sammy's is upscale yet casual. A must dine place. It's been around for 80 years, and has been through 3 generations A++++++++
CindysDelish.comJanuary 29, 2012
Place doesnt even have sign its a plain old white house. Would not know it was even there except for the cars parked in the area. Steaks and seafood are very good. Listed in PiggOuts.com
Carl DubovyNovember 28, 2011
our favorite place for the past 35 yrs. we bring our children here since age 3 yrs, now they are 37 yrs old. need to say anything more?
Nancy P.September 2, 2013
Shrimp scampi, penne vodka and garlic oil spaghetti are all must haves!
Erika BarningerDecember 1, 2012
The specialty cider martinis are especially delicious!!
Roland LangnerMay 19, 2010
Make sure while you're at the bar you ask to see where they pumped the hooch from across the street at the Cider Mill during prohibition :)
tiva formanApril 1, 2012
garlic spaghetti & lobster. wear a bib!

20 Photos